Slice of Bay Shore

Not the best when you first take a bite out of it

I’m from Brooklyn and I know good pizza. Definitely stop by this place. Outside seating on main street can’t go wrong

A decent enough slice of pizza. Small bump for the garlic knots too.

Very good slice. Crust is thin and crispy

Very good crust, cheese had good flavor but sauce could use more flavor... however the vodka slice was a solid 8.9

Not a bad slice , super crunchy and light grease. Sauce doesn’t have much flavor but would deff come back

Loved the sweet sauce and ratio to cheese. Crust crispy but not thoroughly cooked through. Good flop. No grease drip at all. Wanted to love it but seemed as if it was cooked too quickly before closing up for the night. Happy National Pizza Day! This one fell a bit short.

Not a bad slice! Tasty sauce, dough was a bit undercooked, the way I like it!

sauce is odd, flop is wild

Solid slice. Crispy crust, good sauce and cheese.

Got a regular and a grandma. I like cheese but the regular probably can throttle back a little. The grandma was decent