Slice of Italy By Tony's

Researched best Grandma Pie near me. Slice of Italy ranked third. Nah… ordered pepp & mush on one half, rest original Grandma. Ordered well done. Crust thickness was somewhere between standard pie and Sicilian. Not as crunchy or buttery as I would have hoped. Pie was good, but basil taste overwhelmed the palette. Slight garlic notes as expected. Honestly, the basil was so strong that I could barely taste the pepperoni and mushrooms. Mushrooms were canned, not fresh, an automatic half point deduction for me. Now, it was decent to be fair, just nothing exceptional and not worth extra effort to get to.

Soft not much crunch. Flavor is good. On the greasier side

Tons of flop and not a lot of flavor. Sauce and crust was decent.

Crunchy crust, good looking bubbles on the crust. Italian restaurant first. Good looking pie. Not too much sauce but cheese is just right.

I wish I can go back and change my review for Cavazullos in Emmaus, I messed up the review and didn't score it before I hit submit. Only Cavazullos is worse than Slice of Italy in this area. Dough is chewy, and it is greasy beyond belief.

Good pizza. Done perfectly. Decent sauce and cheese. Didn’t wow me but very good and a solid choice for the area.

Had high hopes but was let down... thick doughy slice with little flavor. Their saving grace was I just came home from the Mecca of bad pizza...

Serious ovens banging out lots of pies tonight! Great sauce and crust, I like bubbles. Just a little more crisp would be good, lots of cheese there. Server and the owner are nice, we’ll be back...

Solid slices, but a little doughy. Dough could use a little more flavor too, but a overall good slices

Have had their plain before. Solid place. Good sauce. Deserving score.

Pretty good sauce, cheese great, perfect crisp, but since the cheese is heavy it's got that Pennsylvania flop

Very good. First time having it and it was this grandmas style. Looking forward to trying their regular cheese

Definitely a good football pizza. We asked for it cooked well done, but unfortunately had to cook it further in the oven when we got home. Crust is really good, but the sauce is bland. We had to try a slice of their Grandma’s pizza; it is better than their round pizza and would give it a 7.2.

Good pizza for this area. The quality is not always consistent every time I go, but I will put it up against most other slices available in the vicinity. They make great sandwiches and other food here too.

Slice of Italy, very clean restaurant. Would recommend as good football pizza