Sofia Pizza Shoppe

This is a quality slice of pizza. Classic NYC style, pretty thin, has great crust and the cheese is good too. A bit oily for my liking but overall this is solid.

Cheese 7.3 Pepperoni 7.1 Margherita 5.7 Great little pizza shop! Cheese and Pep were incredible! The crust is worth the trip!

Solid pizza. Best part was the crust. Had the right amount of crisp. Sauce had a good sweet taste to it, but not mind-blowing. Was a little greasy, but overall this is a solid spot. Nice guy running it and quality service. Would definitely revisit

Awesome slice. Perfectly crisp crust with just the right cheese to sauce ratio. My only complaint is that there isn’t any superstar here — every part of this slice is good, but not trying to steal the show

The picture says it all.

Good pizza. Little greasy. Very solid. Would get again

Quintessential Ny slice here thin and saucy too great tasting cheese and crunchy crust great slice. The grandma is gonna be a 7.9 dough was a little bit chewy but not bad was hoping for more crisp but the garlic was off the charts and great tasting sauce from it fresh mozz and basil were great just needed another minute.

Great crisp crust. Good flavor. Sauce needs a little more "kick" to it.

Light thin slice. Awesome tang in the sauce & crispy crust. Not a must have but definitely worth it

Softer crust I like. Grease is just perfect. Excellent cheese. Great slice!

Standard New York slice but great flavor. Good cheese-sauce combo. Could be crispier on the crust. Lots of flop.

Great flavor in the spinach pizza.

Great Pie. Had the Pepperoni Pie I would actually rate that a 8 and the cheese pie 7.6. Combined giving a solid 7.8 . Overall great cheese and great tasting sauce. If you are somewhere midtown East great pizza shop to try

Tried a number of different slices and there’s a big range here from a 6.1- 8.1 with most being around a 7.5. Not much flavor to most slices and stale bread on the Sicilian slice. Disappointing for a former Top 100 in the country.

Great crisp, not enough cheese, solid sauce, great slice but I may have gotten one that had been sitting for a while.

Solid slice, love the crunchiness of the crust.