Sonny Red's

Rare to find a wing spot that does pizza well and vice versa. Sonny Red’s pepperoni pizza is outstanding.

I’ve been wanting to try this place but somehow overlooked it until now... This place is almost averaging an 8! Let’s get onto why it isn’t an 8 score pizza. The dough is good, not same day fresh but close. For the amount of char on the bottom, this pizza should be crispy! In fact, it was undercooked and the only crispy part was the crust. The sauce was there but missing any noticeable flavors. I did get a slightly sweet taste but nothing else. The cheese saved this pizza, it’s fresh, chewy and delicious. For a thinner style pizza, it’s unfortunate they undercooked it. Overall, they have everything needed for a 8.7 or higher pizza. I don’t want to give it a 7.1 but I must based on this experience.

My favorite pizza in the western N.Y. area, old Smokey

Fresh. Crust is amazing

A nice change from the typical Buffalo pizzeria slice. Neapolitan pizza. Light and tasty. Solid 7.6

Very good slice...would recommend the Colonel Angus. Neapolitan slice with crispy crust, could use a little more cheese