Sonny's Pizzeria

My couch got destroyed from eating this pizza. 4.2

Pretty meh. I expected better, but it doesn't do well to satisfy me. I thought their NY slice would be better, but it was proven otherwise. (Disclaimer: I ate this in June, score may have changed over time)

Kind of ok. It was cheesy as fuck but nothing special. They had options between neopolitan or however tf u spell it and NY. I took the NY slice bc I hate neapolitan (idk how to spell it I'm fucktarded)

Decent Chicago style pizza. Greasy. Thick. Doughy

Restaurant has an awesome atmosphere. Pizza had a great taste and a great crisp to the crust. Could use a bit more sauce and a bit more cheese, but everything else was perfect.

Pizza was ok. Hoping for the crust to be a little crispier. Good sauce. A little greasy. Asked for light sauce and for the pizza to be well done, which I think it was.

The crust was not my favorite and it needed to be cooked longer. It’s just ok pizza.

We were in town to visit the beautiful Door County summer activities when we got hungry. Looked up the local take out and Sonny’s popped up. Cool looking place right on the water, we were hoping the pizza would be as good as the place was cool. Boy we’re we disappointed. The pizza was average at best. There was ZERO difference between the normal thin crust pizza we got and the specialty Neapolitan style that we also got. Don’t get me wrong, average pizza is still better than eating ANY vegetables, but this is just that: average pizza at best.

Everybody knows the rules. Great crisp, fresh ingredients. I'm a Neopolitan guy so that inflates the score a bit, but 8.5.

Pretty good not great

The neopolitan pizza isn't neopolitan. The thick crust pizza tastes like lunchroom pizza.

Solid

Nice crisp. Decent sauce and cheese. Definitely not bad for the area. This is one of their “neopolitan” pizzas which I believe to be their best pizzas.