South Shore Tiki Lounge

Great New York style pizza. The crust was crispy. No flop! Toppings were fantastic! Best on the island!

Decent cheese pie. Crust was pretty thin and crunchy. Tasty. Nothing to call home about but one of the better pizzas I've had on Maui so far.

Inconsistent. Depending on who's cooking that night you can have a fantastic pizza or a flat, unimpressive, minimal toppings pizza. I would say about 75% of the time it's great. But that 25% of the time it will look like someone smashed your pizza with an anvil and/or only put half the amount of toppings on that they should have. Gonna give a 5 out of 10 becaus of the inconsistency and I feel bad about it because who ever is cooking the majority of the time does a fantastic job but the weakest link effects the rest of the chain.

Alright Frankie... Tried 2 slices: the first (and pictured) was a build your own. Good not great, little undersized though. Just a 6 inch pie, but crispy and tasted good. The second was a menu listed Margherita pizza. It was subpar. The whole milk mozzarella was a little too thick and I was just not a fan. Grading off the first pie, 7.1. Book it

Aight frankie this pizza looks like a 10 which is what brought us here but tastes like a 5.2. Flavorless, frozen pizza style crust, barely any pizza sauce and cheap mozzarella.

Too thin crust that was burnt. Too little pizza sauce (so i have no idea how the sauce was) with way too much cheese. It I ate here again, i would order light cheese and extra sauce.