Order it well done and it could get into the 9s
apeinahellcat2/18/23, 8:41 p.m.
Super thin great quality pizza definitely was worth the drive for sure
adam.zurbriggen11/26/22, 8:21 p.m.
Excellent crisp. Sauce could be a bit more robust but other than that excellent.
lennoll19/9/22, 2:20 a.m.
Great crunchy crust on the edges but undercarriage gets too soft by the middle. Sauce is quite good.
jerseypies8/13/22, 12:02 p.m.
Super thin, super light, and full of flavor. Sauce made your eyes pop! It’s always impressive how you can get so much flavor in such a thin bite. You could eat this whole thing and not feel like a fat piece of shit, which any pizza lover appreciates.
thatsmrtoyou7/20/22, 3:53 p.m.
One sentence everybody knows the rules! Crispy pie that thankfully I had other toppings on to give it some flavor was just ok. That’s a review!
marcoeatspizza5/6/22, 1:02 a.m.
Very good pizza, particularly the taste of the cheese, and great atmosphere inside. Had both the regular cheese pie and grandma pie, and highly recommend the grandma slice.
ryan.rutherford9/26/21, 6:43 p.m.
Squan Tavern has been serving up quality pizza pies since 1964. Bigger than a bar pie and a style that resembles more of a tavern pie, it’s a respectable size, thin, with decent firmness. The cheese has a very distinct flavor, a stringy flow, melted well but pulls with each bite. It’s a very tasty blend with some sharpness and a hint of oregano. Unfortunately, the sauce is a bit silenced in both quantity and quality. Add another ladle to the pie and perhaps the flavor of the sauce will come through; otherwise, I feel like it needs more spice to give it some kick. Luckily, the crust is outstanding and saves the entire pie. Crispy, crunchy, fantastic taste & texture, the crust is easily the star. Definitely a pretty good pizza overall, with a few sauce adjustments, it could easily climb into the 8s.
lisa.gentile8/28/21, 12:34 a.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules. Flop at first so knife and forked it the first bite but tasty overall
kristen.ochs8/23/21, 1:29 p.m.
Slightly above average pizza. Sauce is a touch too sweet for me and crust could be more well done. Definitely needed to add a bit of salt and crushed red pepper to flavor the margarita. Sausage pepper and onion pie had a lot of flavor.
travis.north8/23/21, 12:16 a.m.
From Henry(9) : it’s pizza, cheese is too flappy and hit my chin. Place is good.
bob.d.6/25/21, 12:20 a.m.
Sauce tastes fake and sweet- like tomato paste with sugar. Pretty standard. Not great. Crust is good
chris.jf076/18/21, 7:21 p.m.
Yet another very good Jersey Shore pizza spot! The pizza has very good crisp and flavor. I was between a 7.9 and 8.1. The crisp put me over the top and made me go with my 8.1 score.
mike.m406/14/21, 12:39 a.m.
This is a pretty good quality pie. Nice crisp, ingredients are good. If you live in the neighborhood, you’d get it, but not a pizza you’d travel for.
dennis.schweitzer jr6/9/21, 8:03 p.m.
Get grandmas pizza now !!! Most amazing pizza you will ever eat