Square Pie

Eats like a mix of Detroit style and Sicilian. Crispy edges, fluffy buttery crust. Great cheese and sauce. Phenomenal

Review 504 $15.00 small .. very fluffy dough kind of deep dish-ish. Very good crisp to crust and undercarriage. Delicious sauce cheese a little lack luster but this is not an every week pizza it’s a once every couple months. Wish it was thinner would have been a bit better was really leaning towards 7.9 but the crunch u pushed it up

Fantastic pizza, think Dave is wrong, should be an 8.2 min. Crust is superb, sauce is delicious, and on top where it should be.

Very airy crust. Really liked the sauce and pepperoni. Seemed a little light on the cheese for my tastes. Very straightforward menu and a very good pie.

Drove over an hour to check this place out. Good variety of pizza and other items to choose from. Pizza was awesome, I had the Soppresetta red pie. Definitley something unique, fresh ingredients, awesome all around. Washed it down with a Boylan cane suger cola. The service was awesome as well, friendly and helpful. Will make the drive again. This place kicks ass!

SEA MONSTER

Very good za. I can see this getting into the 8s if you eat it there. Delivery always hurts the score a bit. Crust a bit too fluffy. Like the cheese bottom. Could use more sauce for sure.

The buttery flaky crust very enjoyable. A delicious change up from the standard pie and although I am very critical of sweet Sauce, this is a nice combination with the crust.

The tits

Not a huge fan of french bread pizza with that being said I would eat this once a week. Thick doughy crunchy crust that melts in your mouth. Good sauce ratio but could do with a little more cheese. I want to come back and try with other toppings.

Great undercarriage

They just opened up dine in again after 3 years and holy heaven in a sourdough fluffy crust. Better than Chicago, Detroit, NYC and NJ. I still lovely my Brooklyn’s in Hackensack, but this pie is just literal heaven in every way. You’ve got to taste it to believe it’s possible to achieve this level of insanity.

Simply incredible. The only competition to circles and squares in the city

This review is going to be one of my weirder ones. I didn’t like this pizza. However, everything was great and the crisp was incredible. I was just so heavy! I’m more of a thinner crust/football style pizza. The Detroit style/Sicilian style that this is wasn’t for me. However, it’s obviously for others. My pickiness will not impact this score.

Too thick. Taste nothing special. Great execution. Great undercarriage. No one ingredient jumps out taste-wise. Sauce pretty decent but since not enough it knocks down score. Bonus review- porchetta, is better. Still too thick for my taste. Meat real good. 7.2 That’s a review. Yet another underwhelming joint.

Great square

A great deep dish style pizza. A little greasy but the crust was light and crispy. A must try!