St. Augie's Pizza

Lots of cheese, kind of thick soft crust . I prefer crispier , less cheese .

Little floppy, good tasting sauce

Really great NY style slice. Excellent crisp. Fresh sauce. Quality cheese blend. Good tasting pizza…just something was missing. Best in the area for sure.

Best in town by far!

Great crust and undercarriage cheese isn’t my favorite flavor but great New York style slice and one of my favorite spots in st Augustine for a slice

Outstanding pizza. Rookie score but it’s appropriate.

Great flavor, the sauce is boss. Perfect NY slice. I’ll be coming back.

Crunchy, flavorful and generally great. They didn’t re-heat it as much as they chocks have so a little off likely. Usually closer to an 8 here.

Nothing like a NY Pie in St. Augustine

Good pizza, not great. A lot of oregano ontop.

Good flavor

I noticed this place late night walking thru town and came to check it out the next morning. I liked the NY style sign outside! 1. I looked them up on the one bite app and their ratings are pretty good. 3. Out of the 3 top places I reviewed in St. Augustine, this place was the best. Amazing cheese, amazing dough and amazing sauce.

Good pizza. Could have been great if less greasy & had crisp. Dough was chewy, absolutely no crisp. Minimal flop. Solid college pie. Even with the score it was one of the better spots in St. Augustine.

No one should ever rate this above a 4. Dominos is a better option. Greasy, too much flop, no crisp on the crust.

Wow! Staff is a little lethargic. Inside was dead at the time I went. But what a phenomenal slice! If you want real authentic NY style pizza this is the best I’ve had since moving to Florida! Just a little greasy and floppy but an awesome slice!

Best pizza in st Augustine and probably Jax too

Solid crunch medium flop unique tangy sauce and good cheese

Good crust and tangy sauce

Another pleasant surprise. I read great reviews, but was still skeptical. Crust was great. A little floppy toward the center, but a decent undercarriage as you moved back. Sauce and cheese were both solid. Nothing too crazy. Would definitely do again.