Excellent pizza. Was pleasantly surprised. I took an awesome pic too.
john.summers jr2/15/21, 8:05 p.m.
Very good thin crust pizza. I like the crust a little more firm. The sauce and cheese are delicious.
roda11471/20/21, 1:26 a.m.
Super flopy and greasy but pretty tasty. On the lower end of bar pies but still good. Rookie score of seven because its better then the 6's and not quite 7's. Employees were very nice they forgot to put my order in but gave me an extra pie free of charge. Reminds me of Vic's but better sauce
alexander.lopez11/16/21, 7:45 p.m.
A respectable 7.7. Good, solid bar pie that gets the job done. The overall flavor profile is pretty standard. Nothing that really jumps out. Under-carriage has a slight crunch I'm really digging. As you can see, there is flop. Gets better as it cools down.
john.johnson311/2/21, 1:02 p.m.
Great bar pizza. The cheese and tomato sauce blend really well together and taste great. Score would’ve been a little higher if bottom crust was a little crispier.
phillypizzaguy12310/5/20, 5:49 p.m.
Very light crust. A little greasy and not as crispy as I expected. Good slice nonetheless.
patrick.brown126/13/20, 5:49 p.m.
Too much flop for bar pizza. Needs to be crispier. But their white spinach was better (7.2 on the white)
pfoley575/1/20, 11:31 p.m.
Pizza is very good. You need to be in the bar pounding a Coors Light and make sure to get the pie well done.
ryan.rutherford4/24/20, 8:32 p.m.
If you’re from North Jersey, you already know; if you’re from out of state, you probably won’t understand but when it comes to bar pies, this is about as good as it gets. Serving some of the best thin crust pizza for over 65 years, Star Tavern has achieved legendary status in NJ. Very simple, very tasty, thin, crispy and delicious bar pies at their best. Nothing fancy about the cheese, sauce or dough but it all works together to give you that old school neighborhood bar pie flavor that can’t be duplicated by your average pizzeria. It’s very easy to finish an entire pie by yourself, so order a bunch if you’re with a group of people. And it doesn’t travel particularly well, much better to eat on site, hot & fresh. A lot of sentimental value & nostalgia in my rating but you’d be hard pressed to find anyone from Jersey who has had it before score lower.
raphael.pinheiro3/9/20, 2:17 a.m.
Great bar pizza! Pepperoni was a little bit on the greasy side, but the 3 cheese was amazing. Next time I’d order extra crisp.