8,760 views•94 likes
subdiver6/17/23, 6:30 p.m.
Finally made it up to Star Tavern in Orange, New Jersey for couple of very good bar pies. Super thin, tasty sauce and perfect crispy bottom crust. 8.1/10
pizzart5/24/23, 9:12 p.m.
I’ll improve my rating a little . It’s a “bar pie” and it grew on me on 2nd slice. It had very good crisp on the end point
12 views•1 like
downwithonebite4/1/23, 3:34 a.m.
This is the pizza by which all other pizzas ought to be judged. Whenever I try a new pizza place I ask myself how it compares to Star Tavern. Nothing I have ever tried has topped this, and few places have even come close. The cheese and sauce are both great but what sets this place apart is the crust. This is the ultimate thin crust: perfectly crisp and somehow almost buttery, delicious until the very end. The few downsides of this place are its lack of garlic knots (don't bother trying the garlic bread), the lightness, and the fact it only has one size pie. You'll find the size isn't really an issue, however. It allows you to get the perfect even crispness every time, unlike with other places, where a large can end up soggy. They also have some of the best rootbeer I've ever had. An absolute must-try.
g_man2923/29/23, 9:20 p.m.
A bit too oily even for pepperoni. Prefer the bigger sized pepperoni to the smaller one. Thin crust was good. Held it's shape well. Good pie but not the best I've had either for the style.
ed.drilon2/3/23, 5:50 p.m.
Regrade as I got this one with pepperoni. Simple and just plain good bar pie I don’t know what Dave was thinking in giving this low 7s he should have graded this a high 7/low 8s
pizzasherpa221/12/23, 9:05 p.m.
Not enough crisp for me. Very soupy in the middle and couldn’t hold firmness. Sauce was meh 😒 🍕
tim.kindt12/26/22, 6:22 p.m.
In my opinion Dave rated this way to low. Very, very good. Do not hesitate to try it!
rob.devinney11/7/22, 10:33 p.m.
Not that great of a pie the world famous title is misleading. Unless it’s famous for being the soggiest pizza ever. The sauce was decent so I’ll leave a 5.
markreviewspies10/18/22, 1:45 a.m.
Good bar pie. A little too floppy but actually tasted very good. Cheese and sauce were the best part. More crunch would improve score greatly. Still, great to be back at at Star Tavern
levinemachine9/2/22, 3:04 a.m.
Prototypical bar pie. Thin slices but the dough has a good flavor. Decent amount of tasty and oily cheese. The sauce is mediocre.
portnoy_dont_know_shit6/21/22, 9:40 p.m.
It’s no Kinchleys. Nothing really stood out on this other than it was undercooked. Overall it was ok.
bill.longcor4/16/22, 6:02 p.m.
Displays does not live up to the hype. Pies are small. Sauce and cheese is good quality. The cheese and sauce are browned and well done. But the crust is limp and almost soggy. As far as the crust goes I’ve had better frozen pizza.