Star Tavern

To floppy needs more crisp!!

Very good

I love my babes and pizza thick. This thin crust broad put out well. I’d be sure finished her off next time.

Thin crust bar pie here but I’ve had both this and regular size and they are the same. A little flop but most of crust crispy. We’ll cooked good sauce a tiny bit sweet and cheese def tastes Mafioso. Cheese almost completely covers whole pizza including crust which bought it up couple more notches. Small parking lot and street parking tough but worth the ride

Fantastic

The clam pie is phenomenal

Best thin crust pizza. Soft and flavorful

App was not working at the spot but this pie was of excellent quality. Very thin. Finished with out any slice to take home

A very good bar pie, but still just a bar pie. Uber thin, easy to down nearly the whole thing.

Great flavor but lacking on crispiness.

Very good thin crust pizza. I like the crust a little more firm. The sauce and cheese are delicious.

Great thin crust pizza at Star Tavern, Orange NJ

Super flopy and greasy but pretty tasty. On the lower end of bar pies but still good. Rookie score of seven because its better then the 6's and not quite 7's. Employees were very nice they forgot to put my order in but gave me an extra pie free of charge. Reminds me of Vic's but better sauce

A respectable 7.7. Good, solid bar pie that gets the job done. The overall flavor profile is pretty standard. Nothing that really jumps out. Under-carriage has a slight crunch I'm really digging. As you can see, there is flop. Gets better as it cools down.

Great bar pizza. The cheese and tomato sauce blend really well together and taste great. Score would’ve been a little higher if bottom crust was a little crispier.