Dave prob got a rushed pie or his taste buds were off- this is solid bar pie! Highlights are the tangyness and slightly salty cheese, way better than his 7.1 score…
portnoy_dont_know_shit6/21/22, 9:40 p.m.
It’s no Kinchleys. Nothing really stood out on this other than it was undercooked. Overall it was ok.
cooperlinc6/2/22, 3:34 p.m.
Ordered it light well done.....Maybe next time well done for a little more crisp...Regular would be too floppy......8.1 plain and 7.5 for sausage....Good flavor and slightly greasy, but a good combo with a cold beer....Would defo come back
bill.longcor4/16/22, 6:02 p.m.
Displays does not live up to the hype. Pies are small. Sauce and cheese is good quality. The cheese and sauce are browned and well done. But the crust is limp and almost soggy. As far as the crust goes I’ve had better frozen pizza.
km0113/22/22, 4:35 p.m.
This was one of my first Bar pies from a nationally famous location and I was far from impressed to say the least. Star tavern was ranked as the 36th best pizza place in America on the most recent daily meals list, so I had some very high hopes going in. The pizza itself was very thin, yet had almost no structure and was a floppy mess. You had to do in New York fold, and even still it was difficult to eat, has the grease would drip directly from the tip of each slice as you picked it up. The overall flavor was quite good, but the dough was an absolute deal breaker. I have since been to almost all of the well-known bar pie spots in the South shore, and while bar pie is not my all-time favorite style of pizza, I have had several that were much better than this!
tbg2/23/22, 11:22 p.m.
Got the Everything (minus anchovies). That fucker was mighty tasty….like an ole school howyadoin. Nice sweet crunch of the onions with a lil crunch of the peps, savory sausages and that tangy roni like a succulent milf bum hole on Reddit
biggvis1/2/22, 8:56 p.m.
Always love the pie here. Sauce and cheese right to the crispy edges. Thin crust with a bit of a nice chew
tim.tedesco12/28/21, 2:57 p.m.
Good bar pie. Hot and fresh. Cooked really nicely. One of the top bar pies in the area but not the best. One of those places you know you’re gonna get a good pie everytime, but there are better out there.
john.urbanski412/3/21, 12:23 a.m.
Very good, could have been cooked longer but still a good pie
nick.mauro11/27/21, 8:47 p.m.
This pie was something. Just really hit the spot. It was thin by thin but not floppy but also not toasted crispy. I thought the sauce and cheese were really good together. Just a great bar pie in a great atmosphere
jan.rosenberg111/27/21, 5:24 p.m.
Delicious thin crust pizza. Good tang to sauce. Great bar pie
steviegnj10/23/21, 9:37 p.m.
A little floppy and oily. Crust had good flavor and a lot of flavorful cheese. I would have liked it cooked a little more.