Steel Peel Pizza

I would have given this a higher score but they downsized their large pie. This is more like a medium for the price of a large .. good taste and great crust .. no flop .. no grease ..college pizza .. Boo Eagles ... Go Giants!!!

Definitely a good slice of pizza, I got the white pizza, it had some sleepy tang to it. It wasn’t a smack-ya-right-in-the-face level of garlic, it was just right. Crust was solid and the pizza had a nice thickness to it.

Boardwalk pizza. Great crisp. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. No flop!

Slices are much better than full pies. Slice gets 7.4 but full pies gets 6.5

My pizza looks much different than the others posted on here. Very thick dough, barely any sauce. No real taste to it. The crust was crunchy though

Bland. Not crispy. Not doughy. Tough to describe how plain it is.

Crispy crust, but has some serious floppage. Very cheese coward, can’t really taste the sauce. Resembles football pizza

A nice sweet sauce with cheese. Personally, would be better as a normal pie. Good crust, but I wish it was made like a normal pie. 6.8 Frankie, that’s the review.

Best slice in Lancaster hands down

Not terrible. Lacks flavor and sauce. Good crunch. Plain side better than veggies. Broccoli was not fresh (frozen). Excellent service tho.

Honey and Ricotta - 7.7 Boardwalk - 6.9

Cool spot with solid football pizza!

Boardwalk slice