You have to get their Sicilian, regular pie is not even close to as good. Speaking on the Sicilian - amazing crust, super crunchy. Sauce is on the sweet side and really good. Cheese is always the perfect amount and really good too. I’ve been coming here for twenty years and have never once had an even close to bad Sicilian. I’ve been told they ship these all over the country to people that have moved and still want one, not surprised one bit by that. 👍🏼👍🏼
joeyb3312/19/20, 5:29 p.m.
Nothing to write home about in the plain slice, other than a nice crunch. The Sicilian on the other hand is delicious.
weekendpizza-er12/19/20, 5:28 p.m.
Rating regular slice - only had one left so had to split it. Crust was a bit too crispy. Sauce and cheese good but nothing special. You come here for the Sicilian pizza.
d-rock11/8/20, 12:15 a.m.
Very solid pizza. Crust is little doughy. Good taste in the sauce and cheese. Football pizza
steven.hunsberger6/13/20, 10:03 p.m.
Ok my second review of Steve’s! I gave them a SOLID 7.9 last time on their square pie. For me that is a super good score. Even then I was teetering on an 8 but that 1/10 of a percent jeopardized my professional review capabilities, because a .0 anything is amateur:) well I tried their traditional round pie and they again got me into the 7’s. Problem is the pizza was picked up late and was on the cool side..... total bummer and our fault! Based on the lack of crisp, and the cooler temp, I increased the score .2 to be fair. My gut score was a 7.2. In any event nice sauce, a little floppy, but that is normal for Lehigh Valley Pizza but I’m not sure even hit it would have had crisp to it. All I’m all Steve’s is an excellent pizzeria, with a good solid pie for any occasion.
one-bite-n-pa4/16/20, 12:15 a.m.
Double slice fresh from the oven. Excellent, tasty and a mainstay in the area forever. Give it a try
jimmy.the maker2/15/20, 11:46 p.m.
Really good. Fluffy. Light. Crispy crust. Great cheese and sauce to dough ratio.
aaron.gasparetti2/4/20, 5:31 p.m.
Looks deceive. Thought it was going to be one of the better slices. Greasy and major flop even though it is a thin slice. Crust has little to no taste, almost stale like. Cheese and sauce are just okay.
fyrfytr826/28/19, 10:03 p.m.
Old favorite that’s maybe seen better days but I still like it...not a tangy sauce but tasty. Side review for the Sicilian is 8.9
dan.schaffer5/29/19, 12:31 a.m.
Little bit of flop, sauce had a little tang, overall a solid pie
brennan.mccarthy4/26/19, 11:12 p.m.
Good but not great. Flavor is missing something. Heard the Sicilian slice is the best.
ralph_pizzum2/6/19, 12:00 a.m.
Pretty good... little flop, little grease, good taste. A little too doughy on the crust, but not gonna penalize for that. Overall, a solid pie!
pirmigrin1/16/19, 5:12 p.m.
No flop at all with a bit of grease. Light on the sauce to cheese ration. Nice crunch on the dough. The Sicilian is the real star here.