Stony Brook Pizza

This undercooked pizza is a major disappointment. The raw dough and lack of flavor make for an unpleasant eating experience. It's a culinary letdown

Decent slice. Had alright crisp and taste but nothing great. Very average slice.

Buffalo chicken slice

Floppy and doughy. Nothing special.

Had some flop. Crust had a different taste. Overall a decent slice

Not sure the other reviews are lining up with mine. The slice simple and had all the key elements 1- crispness 2- well cooked with a solid undercarriage and 3 - good with a tangy sauce - that makes for a solid Long Island Football slice. A lot better than many other places and one the better ones in the general area.

A little fluffy, not a lot of crunch, sauce a little bland, overall an okay slice.

Good football pizza. No drip, had some nice crunch and it was nice having a pizza without the Long Island sloppy flop. Like other reviews, there’s a tang to the sauce, that’s the only thing hurting the pizza. Otherwise It’s enjoyable neighborhood pizza

Good pizza . Ask well done so you get that crisp . Sauce good

I’m really surprised by all the low scoring on this place, wow. I liked it a lot. Maybe hearing that crunch when you take every bite means more to me then most. Everybody is looking for something, right?? If this had more cheese on it, I’d have scored it even higher. Sauce did have a slight tang but nothing that I didn’t like... crust was good. Zero flop, zeroooo. My kinda pizza right here.

Not bad at all. Would I go out of my way to come here for a slice? Probably not but, if I lived in the neighborhood or happened to be driving by, I'd eat this pizza on the regular. Nothing really stood out about this slice just a basic decent pizza.

Very meh, not much flavor in the sauce, was passable if you're really hungry, but has weird after taste. Nice crunch which is what made pushed this over a slight 6