Stuccio's Pizzeria

Had two slices of the pie and it wasn’t how it’s scored by others. Don’t understand these scores. Had a coworker try it and he said it was edible but that’s it. Might be the worst pizza I had in a long time. Hate to leave a score so low. Maybe it’s not my kinda of plain round pie. Not a fan at all

Thin style pie a bit soupy on the top otherwise a unique flavor to it. Cheese stands out for me

Great Pie. Crust is excellent, sauce just sweet enough. So glad I stopped by.

Really good crust and cheese, a little more sauce and I’d put an 8 on it! Drove an hour on the coldest day ever for it, no regrets

Not as much sauce as I typically like but great crust and flavor. Very balanced

Taste-really good, a tad sweet in a good way. Killer undercarriage. Ratio not perfect. Just a tad on thick and doughy side, but ratio very close to excellent. Initial visual inspection I thought was lame but one bite (literally) proved me wrong. For nowhere PA I’m knocked out. Eagles fans and serious Philly pizza connoisseurs encouraged to go here. Cowboys and Giants fans stay away, McDonald’s is down the road.

Everything about this pizza, I have to say is as close to “just right” as it can get for a football pizza. Crust had a good crisp even when the pizza had cooled and had a decent flavor; not too thin and not too thick, no flop and still has that New York thin crust vibe. They also advertise a thick crust for additional charge, or a “party” square pizza. Probably the best part of this pizza was the sauce- overall excellent flavor with a perfect sweetness to it. Almost has a beach pizza vibe but much better. A pizza with extra cheese is advertised, however, I got a pizza with normal cheese, and the amount of cheese was perfect- not too much, not too little, and it had a good flavor. There was some grease, but it was not by any means overpowering. Even better, this large pie only cost about 10 bucks! For what I got for that price, this place is a no-brainer. Dave, if you are ever in this area, this place is without a doubt worth the drive. Best football/NY pizza in the Bloomsburg & Berwick area hands down.

Greasy, little soupy in the middle, other wise pretty good. The dude who gave it a 9.4 is psychotic.

I got no picture of this pizza, but I live a block away now, and I have to say, when you first open the box, 90% of the time they throw the damn pizza in so forcefully all the cheese shifts to the back. HOWEVER after moving some cheese around, I have to say, this pizza is incredible. It's the sauce that does it. Not too much crisp in the dough, but that didn't bother me at all the sauce is ABSOLUTELY MINT. When I say I got lucky finding a home near this place, I mean I got super lucky. Next time I'll order it a bit crispier than they usually do, but seriously this is the good stuff. I've had pizzas I thought were absolute garbage I just gave a place getting 7.0s on this app a 1.9 and that was generous, I've eaten from every pizza place I seen, this place is unbelievable. But if you guys see this stop being so aggressive when throwing the pie in the box.

This pizza is perfectly balanced. Cheese, sweeter sauce. Crist is crispy. It is oily which i like. It isn't good eaten cold in my opinion, but perfect upon pick up. Reminds me of Pizza Shackamaxon in Philly but a tad bit better.

AB 7.5

Good crisp. Sauce is unique. Good cheese.

I’m writing this review with a legitimate score based on a similar criteria to Pres to help those really interested in finding the best pizza. Too many people on here going to their hometown shop and giving them a ridiculous score. I just returned from a Miami trip where I tried Mister O1 pizza that Pres gave an 8.9. Based on that being fresh on my tongue Stuccio’s is a LEGITIMATE 9.4! Would be higher if the cooks were more consistent. One thing I have to say is, like most places, it depends who cooks the pie whether you get that perfect bottom crisp. Come on guys! You have an amazing product, don’t let your customers down with soggy bottom pizza. When this pizza is at it’s best it’s alight and fluffy as you bite through until you get that bottom crisp. The flavor and combination of sauce, cheese, and thin crust is amazing. Truly something special and worth a drive (anything over and 8.0 according to Dave). I plan on going through the areas best pizzas and recalibrating these scores for some sense of legitimacy for those who really care about pizza.

Good pizza. Needed to be crisper but still no Flop. Love the sause. Nice and sweet!

Sauce is sweet and the dough was cooked perfect, thin and crispy. The best around Bloomsburg by far!

Went here yesterday don’t have the box because it was so good I ate it all thin and very crispy a perfect blend of flavor This is a textbook Dave style pizza