Sugar River Pizza Co. - Verona

Alright Frankie… at first glance we’ve got a nice looking football pizza. There is a nice crispy look to the cheese and the crust. As I grab a slice, there is flop. There is a little grease in the cheese but the cheese is bubbled up nice and has a good taste. The sauce is your average football pie sauce. Pretty decent crunch on the crust. Overall to me, this is just like a Papa Johns/Pizza Hut type football pie but tastier.

Phenomenal tang in the sauce. Crust was fluffy but a nice crisp. Totally high end ingredients. Love this pie! Spin dip was fire too. 🔥

Gimmick pizzas but very good. Basic pizza not the best.

Solid doughy for a thin crust nice crisp tho overall solid

Average pizza I would eat it again

wings are so so. taco pizza is good but MESSY

Got wings for an app, 10 piece, got 9 about the size of my thumb. Taco pizza is great, though.

A little flop, but amazing cheese. And crust. Pepperoni was amazing!!! Also the bone in hot wings were amazing

Decent flop solid slice

Some of the best pizza around. The New Glarus location is a wee bit better (probably a 9.1). But this pizza is absolutely delicious!