Had high expectations based on some rave reviews. A little overrated in my opinion. Crust was very good but had a lot of grease on it, flavor was good, but not great. Definitely prefer Black Sheep and El Mar in Plymouth over Surly, but good overall. The rest of their menu is fantastic.
airmen6/23/22, 4:25 a.m.
Absolutely amazing! Presentation was perfect. Flavor was epic! Barely any flop!
kingbiega5/21/22, 7:41 p.m.
Very delicious pizza but don’t sprinkle Parmesan cheese on my pizza when I don’t ask for it
tedleroux19914/1/22, 11:52 p.m.
Crust is great. The body is good, not great. Still one of the best in the area.
dylan.johnson122/20/22, 9:39 p.m.
As far as thin crust pizza goes this is some of the best. I’m more of a thick crust person but this pizza was great. Really cool place. Don’t get the desserts in the pizza area upstairs because they are literally just twinkies.
taylor.pettis10/31/21, 12:42 a.m.
The crust at this place is absolutely amazing! Easily one of the favorites I’ve tasted. I do have some mixed opinions on the toppings. Overall, really good pizza, you won’t be disappointed.
newjerseydevil10/2/21, 3:41 a.m.
Awesome place. Huge area. Lots to do and 40+ Beers. Now for the pizza. Great char. I got the “I’m your Daddy”. Pepperoni, hot peppers and honey.
mike.ganrude5/6/21, 1:47 a.m.
Surly can hang with the best of them. Crispy crust and a sweet sauce. I miss this place, hope they open again soon
matt.weide9/30/20, 6:58 p.m.
Well executed wood fired pizza, I marked it down for the sauce that I found bland.
andy.poulsen8/14/20, 12:47 a.m.
Overall very very good, Crust is absolutely perfect! Cheese was a little fancy and it left a Great Lakes worth of grease on top! Would definitely recommend though, great pie. And the place has a great vibe.
chris.mallon7/20/20, 12:08 a.m.
Good crispy crust, right out of the over so a little bit of flop. The one with bacon (McFly) on it had very thick cuts of bacon. Really solid pizza.
ross.gerber6/25/20, 1:31 a.m.
Reviewing a cheese and a McFly at Surly. Very strong. Great crunch. Better than Young Joni and Black Sheep. Elite.
pizzamichigan6/23/20, 11:54 p.m.
A little greasy and did not have very much pepperoni. But I love the charred crust and has great twang to it. I left not feeling miserable either because of the thin crust.