I came across this place by accident while driving .. they had a sign that says Home of the famous Tavern pie.. I had to give it a try. Grew up eating New York pizza and this pie blew me away. I never tasted anything like this , a perfect sweet sauce with a crisp crust, I consider this one of the best pies I had in my life and could see why they are famous for it. I would certainly come back again! ( P.S. The chicken vodka slice we had while waiting on our pie was just as tasty)
youhadmeatpizza4/19/21, 12:23 a.m.
Looks can be deceiving my friends! Way too much oregano and way to sweet.
nicole.pometti2/14/21, 8:11 p.m.
Jenny and I were excited for the Tavern Pie, thin and crispy is our favorite type of Pizza. We are there and had a soup and salad to start, which were fantastic. The service was attentive and great. I wish all these things could make up for the pizza. Unfortunately, the pizza looks great but doesn’t taste it. It reminded us of Chuck E Cheese Pizza and even 7/11. Granted it’s better than those but the taste threw us off. They put everything out the kitchen sink on it but it didn’t blend very well. However, I think I will go back and try their regular pie cause this place has great food- it’s just not the tavern pie.
mr.saturdaynight5/22/20, 3:57 p.m.
A thin slice with a good amount of oil and cheese. The slightest of flop with a semi-crispy crust. Way too much seasonings on the pizza.
christian.bell922/20/20, 8:28 p.m.
A little greasy but that good grease lol zero flop great sauce good cheese thin crust bar pizza crispy it’s called the tavern pie
meganmccrivera2/14/20, 10:48 p.m.
Alright Frankie, you gotta get to TJ’s! You don’t know what you’re missing. Best pizza around!! 🍕
kevin.mccormack12/14/20, 10:14 p.m.
How has Dave not been here yet?? Best pizza around hands down!! Whoever created the tavern pie deserves an award! Best slice I’ve ever had!!
rachel.meyer12/12/20, 12:55 a.m.
Amazing, most outstanding pizza in jersey! Stopped in for a quick bite, all I can say is fan frickin tastic
john.g61/3/20, 8:34 p.m.
Always a good solid slice. Crust is always pretty crispy. Cheese could be alittle lighter IMO.
johnnylyft11/27/19, 12:39 a.m.
Classic football Pizza. Great family owned business. The pizza (we asked for well done) was cooked perfectly. The cheese was flavorful and the sauce had a nice tang to it. Nice crisp. Sicilian pie was big and another go to! I would recommend these guys without reservation. Solid 7.4
matt.colon8/3/19, 1:12 a.m.
So I've been going to these guys for over 15 years. I've grown up on their pizza, and it's sad to say that I've never had a Tavern pie until now. To start the sauce was amazing on the sweet side which I prefer on pizza. I will say I thought it was going to be crisper, so it did have a decent flop. I love pizza crust, and was sceptical bc it has none, but I was extremely happy with this pie.
mike.oxfloppin4/26/19, 7:36 p.m.
Football pizza. More cheese than sauce which makes the pizza feng shui off a bit. Intimate setting inside
96 views•1 like
headshoes3/30/19, 5:06 p.m.
The Tavern Pie... Heavy on the cheese... unique crust with heavy charred edges...
zachary.caruso1/9/19, 9:21 p.m.
Great flavor, but an inctedible amount of grease, big flop action on the tavern slice, but seems like that could've been a fluke. Either way a very fine slice, and a great Margherita slice as well.
george.keklik12/25/18, 11:04 p.m.
Get this pie well done, Frankie. Fresh cheese, tasty sauce, all to accompany the crispy crust.