Both sicilian and Reg Cheese slice on point and makes this place a gem in DSM.I truly love it, but I am not sure how folks around Iowa might like the sauce since it does have that NYC hint of tomato soup type taste to it. Insanity how close of a pizza this is to Joe's Pizza in Manhattan, both slices brought me back to last month eatting @ Joe's. So much so that I had to ask if the owner was from New York, because there isn't a pizza place around that imitates this sauce in Iowa. It was true, a retired NYC Police officer and his wife do infact own this store and opened it up in 2014. Great place to go and same price even as Joe's for a slice of each and a drink ended up under $10. I will be back
extracheesyric9/26/20, 2:19 a.m.
Good sauce, cheese, and crust. A little greasy but I like that
will.shu7/1/20, 7:00 p.m.
Beautiful undercarriage, Crosby crunchy bite to the crust. Good tasting cheese. If there was a little bit less grease it could be next level
tighttastebuds6/27/20, 10:42 p.m.
They have a new location in Johnston. It’s delicious. So good. So good
austin.thayer6/27/20, 12:53 a.m.
Lou is a great guy, he came out and spoke with us while we waited for our pie. Its all there. The crust, the sauce, the toppings. I dont know that you can get anything close to it anywhere else in the city. Great job guys keep it up
john.early2/11/20, 7:25 p.m.
Not a rookie score....it’s not a 7.9 it’s not a 8.1 it’s an 8.0 great crisp great tang just a little greasy
adam.vanhaaften1/2/20, 7:48 p.m.
Combined score. I had cheese and a lasagna slice. Cheese was hot, fresh, little flop. Could eat while driving. Crust a little to dine for me. Sauce was more tang than sweet. I will say 6.1. Now the lasagna slice was cooked better to my liking and toppings opened up much more flavor. Ill go 8.1
joeyspizza11/16/19, 1:38 a.m.
DSM Register had this as the #1 pizza in the metro and yeah it is that damn good, the cheese is perfect along with the sauce and crust, YOWIE WOWIE!! this is some good pie, Dave Portnoy should give it a shot next time he is in the Beastslayer state!! This will burn it down on your tastebuds!! I will dream about this pizza until I return. Phenomenal absolutely phenomenal
cale.kramer8/31/19, 5:32 p.m.
Stepped out of my box. Tried the white pizza with a ricotta. Very crisp and tasty. Pleasantly surprised!
brian.schadler8/17/19, 5:22 p.m.
A lot of good reviews, maybe it’s better to order by the slice, just a river of grease , crust was pretty good though
n8886/21/19, 5:11 p.m.
The only place in Iowa I have been to with real, authentic NY pizza. I do wish they would had a square or Sicilian slice. Owners are straight out of NY and it shows in the looks and taste of their pizza.
eric.bialas5/9/19, 1:29 a.m.
Get the TONY slice. No weakness in this pizza. Good sauce, good crisp, good cheese, good crust.
justin.welvaert4/14/19, 4:32 a.m.
Great New York slice. Would give it a higher score but it’s really greasy!