Terra Mia Pizzeria

Hands down the best and most consistent slice I’ve had in OC from a Long Island guy. Nothing crazy, just a good simple slice

Got 2 slices, 1 had clearly been sitting out a while - pretty bland - 7.1 maybe? Second one was fresh out the oven - much better. Nice crisp and overall a good tasting slice. Only criticism would be a touch on the oily side and while the flavor was good I would’ve liked a bit stronger sauce. For CA pizza - impressive

Easy 7.9. Good crunch, undercarriage has good char, the flop is appropriate, the sauce and cheese are excellent. What keeps this from getting into the eights is I'm not on that level. Perhaps a rescue in the future. Good pizza, that's a review.

Best pizza in south OC

I ordered it well done and extra crispy, which was the right call

🤌🏼

Decent, standard, football pizza. Very basic. More good than bad.

Solid

Better than it looks. Sauce is very flavorful. Soft and crispy crust. Overall good pizza.

Really good slice of pizza. Needed a few more minutes in the oven to get a little crispier. Had some flop to it but I will say it’s the best I have had in OC

One of the best NY-style pizzas I have has in Orange County! Very good look, no flop very nice crisp. I say the sauce needs a bit more of a zip and zest to it. The pizza is missing something and I think it's a tang. However, the crisp of the pizza really makes it worth it.

I’m from NJ, it’s almost like home very very good !!! Yum

Slice is a little on the chewier side, but flavor was good. Some slices may be a little greasier than others, but overall a good pizza!

Quick lunch - very good. Thin and good crisp. Lots of choices - good prices. Worth driving for. I need to go back and try again

Didn’t want to do a rookie score and give it 8.0 but it was 7.9 or 8.1. I think most people are right when they call this the best cheese pizza in Orange County. I think I will struggle to find better. Little on the sweet sauce, but not too much where I’m going to not love the pizza. I think if the pizza had traditional sauce maybe higher score. Perfect crunch all the way through the pizza and the crust was CRUNCH. Not doughy at all throughout the entire pizza. The cheese tasted good very traditional in that regard. Not too much grease which means not too much flop. Amazing pizza! If you’re local you have to try. Bonus score, garlic knots 7.7.

I found the best pizza in Orange County and possibly California. The sauce is unbelievable, nice tang and it’s what makes the pizza IMO. Great cheese. Cooked perfectly. Also great NY style flavor in the crust with some char. A little flop but that’s fine. I’m from Boston, lived in NYC and Chicago so I’m picky with my pies. This one is very good!

Cheese pizza was amazing. Top 2 in OC in my opinion!

Really good pizza if you don’t order when they’re busy. When busy the pizza tends to be inconsistent. Usually meaning overcooked. But when done right, it’s the best pizza in the area by far. Closest to NY pizza but nothing close to places like John’s of Bleeker.

For someone who grew up in NY and now lives in So Cal, this place is one of the best around for a quick NY slice or pie. My only issue is that the pizzas are a little inconsistent. On a good day this place could be a 7.8, but I’m giving it the average score. Still would definitely recommend

Good overall pie; good sauce; nice crust; no flop And I am from the Northeast Region of USA

One bite everybody knows the rules. Score: 9.8 possibly the best pie this side of the Mississippi River. AMAZING. the crunch, the sauce, the toppings. Fabulous. This pie is the real deal. Do not forget the garlic knots Frankie.