The Elmton

Wanted this to be good but it is Not good pizza. Crust is the only redeeming part. Messy, greasy, doughy, thick, hardly any cheese or sauce. Must’ve really gone downhill.

I respect them so much for trying something different. Peppers in the sauce is bad. Swiss cheese is bad. Grease puddles are bad. Not a good pizza.

Obi-Wan Kenobi once said “your eyes can deceive you, don’t trust them.”

Greasy. Doughy Crust with ZERO flavor. Tough to eat. Peppers in the sauce if you like that...won’t be ordering again. I’d recommend going elsewhere for pizza.

Unique, that’s for sure. You’ll either love it or hate it. Wasn’t too fond on the crust, but the sauce and cheese carried it. Very good

This is a pizza you’ll either love or hate, no in between. I love it! One thing you can’t deny is the taste is totally unique.

Not enough sauce, the small amount of sauce that made it on lacked any flavor. It’s a thicker style slice with the grease soaked in like a sponge. No crisp.

Light sauce, with a little tangy taste and large chunks of peppers. The cheese had a good taste, maybe it was fresh! Crust was thick but crisp on the bottom. It was an ok slice of pie!

I think Elmton is delicious. First, the cheese is perfectly melted. Second, the crust has just right amount of crunch. Third, the sauce is tangy yet sweet to my taste buds. Overall, this pizza is fabulous.

Great Pizza!!!! The cheese is different then most and has a distinct taste to it. You can tell it’s a blend and not straight mozzarella. But it is absolutely delicious. Hard pressed to find a better pie.

Heavy grease reduces the score brothers

Very unique pizza. Saying it is the best pizza in Y-Town is a bold statement but... it is the best pizza in Y-Town!