The Exchange Pizza Depot

Buffalo pizza wasn’t great but had so much potential! Needs way more sauce, and I love bacon, but not on a Buffalo pizza.

I love this pizza. This one had some flop, the margarita did not. The crust tastes like old world bread. So damned good.

Good overall, nice crispy crust but too thin in center - floppy

Best pizza in Matthews!

Idk how Sal’s Pizza Factory has a similar score to this place. This is way better. A little too cheesy though

Cheese is great but had little sauce, overall pretty good.

Great pizza for a great price. Perfect singed edges. Tasty quality toppings and amazing unique pizzas of the week. A tiny shack with some of the best tasting pizza I've had. Ps you can pick your own herbs from their garden for your pizza

Good crispy crust, very cheesy, overall good pizza

It was good, I definitely have had better at other places in the area, but it had great flavor, a little doughy, and it had a nice flop at the tip.

No flop sauce is good cheese and toppings taste fresh.

Good cheese spread, pepperoni was crispy. Sauce had decent flavor but nothing that stood out to me. Crust could have used more crispiness. Good after-farmers-market kind of pizza.

If you’re looking for a buffalo chicken pizza. This is the place to go. Zero flop, not overpowered with buffalo sauce, soft crust, thick dough.

The flop was OVERWHELMING! When I picked up a piece ALL of the cheese fell off. Literally all of the cheese. Once I picked up the cheese and put it on the pizza it was actually pretty good. The fact that I had to put it back together is the reason for the low score. If the flop was fixed I’d give it closer to 7. Whoever said this is a 8 or above was obviously drinking a lot of beer or wine at Seaboard. Haha

Best Pizza I've had in a while, and certainly the best I've had in Matthews so far. The only down to it is I wish it was slightly more crispier on the bottom, but otherwise fantastic pizza.

Crust is very good. A little too much flop. Toppings are fresh. Pretty good pizza.