The Galley Pizza & Eatery

Unpopular opinion about my $50 cold pizza and wings… I’m not seeing the hype! It was alright after we reheated it all, but I definitely won’t be running back there anytime soon 🤣

All around solid about pie. Nothing to not like about it in my opinion. It had a bit of a charred taste to it but not in a bad way. There are no joke like 100 pizzas on the menu. We got a Detroit too and it was just ok. Maybe like a 6.7. I would go back and get another bar pie and try another different pizza. The rest of their food looked banging as well.

Bar pie deliciousness

Great flavor, incredibly thin but not a cracker crust. Pepperoni was nice and charred. Service was also fantastic. Highly recommended.

Came and did the bar pie. So good. Better then my last time. Crisp was rockin!!

Bar pie is fucking great.

The hot honey is great !

Crispy, great sauce, fresh ingredients. Winner in Asbury Park.

Nice and thin and crispy and tasty

Ft. Upside down Detroit and chicken vodka. Both VERY good. Detroit style was light and fluffy. Good crisp from the pan. Chicken vodka was like a bar pie. Really good flavors.

Very flavorful and enjoyable slice. They are known for their square pies, but they can surely throw down when it comes to the circle pies as well. No flop, very cheesy and not over oily. The sauce was sweeter and the crust and undercarriage had so good crisp.

Great Pizza and fabulous owner. Bonus review if the Bomb Sandwich which is a 9.9. Order early place get busy.

Detroit upside down pizza

Third review, the Detroit Roni (upside down style) Wow what a freaking amazing pizza. No major complaints at all. Really an amazing pizza!

Great bar pie, and friendly staff! Can’t wait to come back.

Great undercarriage. Crust was perfect. We also tried the square- both fantastic. Sauce was tangy and delicious. I rarely disagree with el pres but this one’s at least a 8.1, I say 8.3.

Incredible pizza served with an ideal ratio of fresh ingredients. The dough is flavorful and cooked perfectly to give it a great chewy consistency with limited flop. The sauce is delicious and savory. The tasty cheese is fresh, chewy and ample amount Is applied on top.

Big bar pie. More flop than I expected but a very good pie. Also got the Detroit style with pepperoni and hot honey. (7.2). I believe it was a special. Very good representation of the style. Great fries, really good wings.

Basic bar pie

Pricy but good. Willing to try out items on menu too