The Grotto Pizzeria

Too doughy and greasy. Cheese has a strange taste. Sauce is very poor quality. It’ll do the job if you’re starving, but that’s about it

Decent slice. Good undercarriage, no flop. Sauce is a little sweet. Overall decent NYC slice on the go.

Below average.

The mushrooms were good, but every other element was completely nondescript

Thick pizza. There was something I really liked about the sauce, but everything else was only alright.

Ok, so I think this place is trying to do better. My office gets it all the time so I have a slice here and there. The cheese doesnt quite have the stinky flavor anymore and the are definitely baking it longer and have added decent char and crisp to the crust. Gettimg closer to an average slice, but still too thick.

Very greasy bro

Cheese to sauce ratio just doesn’t cut it. Grease and this pizza go together like PB&J. Flop was decent but this slice ain’t worth another go

Huge flop. Very oily, no crisp, huge amount of cheese, not much flavor. Reminds me of a pizza from another state. If your a tourist looking for NY pizza don’t eat here.

Great slice! Cheese to sauce ratio perfect. Crust was crispy on outside but soft on the inside

Not terrible and not as much grease as I expected. Cheese was OK, sauce and crust weren’t great but not terrible. Overall, better than I expected given the other reviews.