The New Haven Pizza Co

Good pie. Margarita had too much garlic oil. Other than that, it had a good crisp and crust. Best pizza in the wolcott area.

Good pizza. Cheap cheese. Made it greasy. Normally order cheese. Co-worker wanted sausage n mushroom. But the grease definitely came from the cheese. If they tightened that up, could be a high 8 or even low 9 pizza

Very soft and bland. Took one bite and threw the rest out.

Sausage sub-score: Quality: 6.1 Quantity: 7.1

This is my type

I have no complaints about this pizza. Good flavor to the cheese, sauce and crust. A little soupy if you’re into that, but still holds together well. I could eat this often.

Very very disappointing... under cooked bacon over cooked. Had very high hopes too :(

The best in this area. Unpopular opinion: this place is better than Sally’s in New Haven.

Very good pizza for around here, not a lot of flop, sauce was on point, wasn’t too greasy, crust was great, would definitely recommend!!

Very good football pizza. Just outside of the 8's

Ive been coming here for years and have gotten this same buffalo chicken pizza and it never fails to impress me everytime. They have so many great specialty pizzas its hard to get the cheese. Sure its great too

Solid pizza. Amazing cheese. Great flop. Sauce on point. Wholesome CT pizza

Baked Stuffed Shrimp Pizza

REALLY good pizza. I find it great well done. Good taste, good crust, good sauce. 7.9, that’s a review.