Cheeeeezay!!! Lots of a cheese thin and super greasy but my gawd does it taste good!!! One of the top pizza's in the area (Lyndhurst/rutherford) reminds me of Nancy's Tavern and Ralph's just not as good!! If your reading this and the last 20 reviews "I" (roda1147) did lol😂😂 I obviously didn't eat there in one day. I just ate there before I had the app and yes I stole some pics from google 😂 most are original
meron.rubinowitsch2/10/21, 6:03 p.m.
Exec crispy crust and cheese has nice flavor. Sauce was there but would like a little more.
lennoll12/5/21, 7:30 p.m.
Their “Pizza Italiano” looks amazing here, right? Crust is a little tough though. Still tasty.
matthew.divozzo1/28/21, 11:23 p.m.
Was a tad cheesy for my personal taste but overall super solid. Nice and thin. Would definitely get again.
ryan.rutherford1/18/21, 3:54 p.m.
At first glance, it looks like a large bar pie; but at first taste, it most certainly is not. That’s not to say it’s bad, it just doesn’t have that signature bar pie crisp & taste. The crust is very much bar pie style and the overwhelming star of this pizza, with outstanding crisp & crunch combined with excellent flavor. One of the biggest quandaries of this pie is how can the crust be so crispy, yet the dough is super soft? If the dough could match the crust in crisp, you’re looking at mid-to-high 8s. A couple other issues keeping this pie in the 7s: the cheese is a little too thick for such a thin pizza and it’s producing entirely too much oil. The grease is gushing down each slice, and the flavor of the sauce is completely overmatched by it. Despite several flaws, this is still a very good pie. But if they can crisp the dough up, go a little lighter on the cheese and decrease the oil slick, this pizza has the potential to be great.
tinac13612/9/20, 11:42 p.m.
Outstanding! Just one bite...everyone knows the rules. The pie here has great texture and a nice sauce. Cooked to perfection.
ja420ck10/11/20, 5:36 a.m.
Had both plain and sausage pies. Sausage was crispier than plain. Hair above football pizza. Nothing special.
jesus.uribe2/21/20, 4:17 a.m.
Nice crunch, no flop.. every bite was delicious!! Could be a solid 9.5-10 if I ate it there. Plain TBD
cameron.sirois10/22/19, 7:19 p.m.
Thin pizza, decent flop, great cheese to sauce ratio, good crunch.
joseph.d.nyc10/13/19, 7:42 p.m.
Little disappointing after all the hype I’ve heard for a long time. Thick for a bar pie, Not a lot of flavor. 6.2 is almost generous.
crispycrust696/28/19, 12:27 a.m.
Thin pizza, no flop with great crisp. The sauce is spot on and cheese is delicious. Got over the 8 rating for a bar pizza instead of your typical pizza shop. Would recommend
fredtesta6/11/19, 1:28 p.m.
The New Park Tavern one bite everybody knows the rules The atmosphere and service were great the desert was freakin amazing the pizza was average didn’t care for the dough a little greasy and not a lot of taste ,, fun place to eat pizza pie,,
13 views•5 likes
danielle.russo5/18/19, 1:43 a.m.
Crust was underdone, chewy, and didn’t have a ton of flavor or crisp. Sauce was really good, but way too much cheese.