The Nona Slice House

“The Dr. John” Phenomenal crust which boosts the rating. Little flop despite heavy on the toppings. Best pizza in the area

Lack luster. For all the hype this place gets I was hoping for more. NY style was super greasy and not in a good way. A little too much cheese and not enough crunch. The place has potential for 8+ easy but you’ve gotta go when it’s not as busy, maybe the pies are a little more consistent.

Detroit Style. “Death by Pepperoni”

Get the old world style. One of the best pies in the area.

decent slice terrible service, my plate after one slice it definitely coulda been higher if i didn’t have to wash my hands with degreaser after. definitely not what it was hyped up to be

The staff was great! The Detroit was unbelievable. The sauce was the perfect blend, the golden crisp crust was spectacular. This place is legit for pizza lovers.

New York slice. Easily best I’ve ever had down south. Excellent

Fantastic! Need to try the Detroit style next!

Had an olde world style cheese and a Detroit style pepperoni. Quite possibly the best two pieces of pizza I’ve ever had. Crust is thin and crispy but still filling. The sauce is robust and rich. The cheese is blended perfectly. The Detroit style was fluffy but with an amazing golden brown crunch. I ate it a week ago and still can’t stop thinking about it. If you’re in Tampa/St. Pete/Clearwater, this is a must try.

Bar pizza/thin crust one of the better pizzas around this peninsula!

Wanted to take more pics. One of the best Bianco pies we ever had. Detroit style slaps!

Review #2. Got a Detroit style. Got one Cup n Char Pepperoni and regular Pep. Very crispy, dough is amazing.

Best pizza in Tampa bay, hands down. Great atmosphere as well and always packed even on weekdays. $2 PBR and amazing pizza. How could it not be. This was the Old World Style with cup and char pepperoni, hot honey and ricotta on half.

Did the Dr. John no onion. Wow! Phenomenal crust, a little flop but well worth it! Prob the best in the area.

Best pizza I have had since moving from San Francisco Bay Area to the Tampa Bay Area. Crust had the perfect amount of crisp to it. Everything was really fresh.

Detroit style is what you want. El Diablo is what you need. Light crust, perfectly cooked, not to oily like most Detroit style, great blend of flavors, good quality ingredients. El Diablo in Detroit style... 8.8. the NY style is a 7.2.

Almost a perfect slice. Everything about it is phenomenal!!!

No pizza pic because could not find location on map. Had to use list. Could be best all around pizza place in Tampa Bay Area. New York is excellent. Cooked perfectly (crisp). Detroit is just as good if not better if you like that style.

Pizza here is phenomenal. Tried all 3 styles and I wasn’t disappointed by any of them. Definitely coming back!!

I just scored the simple thin slice an 8.2. This complex Detroit-style pie, complete with crispy edges, was cooked to near perfection. Crispy edges get me every time. It’s sneaky airy too and the taste is awesome. Deserves a rare 9 score…a full 1.0 lift from the thin slice.