This one is good if you like your cheese to taste like rubber. Sauce was good and tangy but you can definitely tell the cheese is not fresh. 6.1
john.holmes11/10/22, 5:31 p.m.
Average at best NY Style pizza. Little flop in the crust- and crust tastes like the already made crust from the grocery store. Sauce is good but cheese has very little taste.
ocrasho2/15/20, 11:41 p.m.
NY Slice Pizza is ok but wasn’t sure why it wasn’t hotter since we had to wait for it. Pizza had way to much oregano on it. Also got an order of pepperoni breadsticks and let me tell you if you love breadsticks these are the worst please for the love of god don’t get these. Breadsticks- 0.3 (side note this is the new location outside the greenwood park mall)
misteronetime9/5/19, 5:38 p.m.
This fuckin’ pizza app got me eatin’ shit pizza at places just to do a review! ™️ Damn good pizza. For Indy this is legit. Crust: Perfectly thin with slight crisp. Excellent, clean dough flavor. Absolutely zero hint of a floury taste. Sauce: Tastes homemade. Fresh, modestly sweet and properly distributed across the dough. Cheese: Very fresh blend. Was a tad oily but overall had great flavor. All in all I’d go back here any day of the week. Pie was well put together.
jarrett.caster6/29/19, 11:53 p.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules... A little bit of New York in Indiana. Good crisp and good sauce. Interested to try the cheese pizza!
john.sanford3/7/19, 6:16 p.m.
One bite everybody knows the rules good pie crust excellent all around taste good...fresh ingredients love it...come vist
austin.armstrong22/22/19, 7:15 p.m.
Easily the best pizza I’ve had in the Indiana...if not the entire midwest
chargerfootball2/17/19, 12:40 a.m.
Absolutely fantastic slice! A little too much flop kept it from being a 9. Next time I’m going to see if I can get it well done and see if that helps the flop. That’s a review 👍🏻
john.hawxby10/25/18, 10:25 p.m.
It was very hot when they brought it out and I’ve been excited for this all day. I think if I had waited for it to actually cool, it would gave only gotten better. It’s fantastic. For it being the same price as the other Indy slices, it’s defiantly a step or two above the rest. Hello to my #1 slice so far!
trace.manspeaker9/21/18, 12:08 a.m.
Great service and hospitality and even better some sexy pizza. Crust was a deal breaker for this score
dinkerhead9/21/18, 12:06 a.m.
Could use better mozzarella cheese, not a lot of flavor but everything else is good. Very limp when picking up with one hand.