The Original Anthony's Pizza

Margherita pizza! Tomatoes were amazing! Nice thin crust with a crunch.

Got a cheese slice today. Comparing it to the pictures, they appear to be inconsistent with their pies. The slice was not bad. Above average. The sauce was good. It has a lot of garlic for more flavor. The crust was cooked but with zero crunch and had almost a stale texture on the inside. The cheese was like glue. Anything it touch, it stuck to. Even the wax paper. Also, the cheese came off all in one peice in my first bite. The flavor of the cheese however was average. Would I come back here again? Nope. Was the pizza bad? No. I give it a 6.2/10

Some just okay football pizza. Cooked to my liking, zero flop, too much grease, sauce isn’t great, crust was nice,and the cheese was fine.

Good football pizza

Very mediocre pie. Nothing jumps out at you. Crust had a good consistency, not too crispy but still had the doughy-er feel I prefer.

Being from NY I would say it’s pretty good. I asked for it well done so there would be no flop.

A average slice but nothing to brag about...very inconsistent...today a 6.1 tomorrow could be a 7.5... It’s like someone different makes your pie every time....nice people and no competition close by