The Original Bizzarro Famous NY Pizza

This is definitely a Dave Portnoy place I think he would score it high, pizza was decent very crispy the cheese was great on it and the staff was awesome.

Sexy beach pie. Dough is the star of this ass shaker. Bla sauce and not high end cheese like you get in NYC. But overall pretty sexy slice.

Basic pie, very doughy, no char. Lots of cheese and greasy. Good florida pizza

Undercarriage was firm but not stiff; cheese & sauce were smooth - not too acidic. drove 30 minutes to get here - would do it again!

Great pizza, slight flop but big slices even on the 14”. Would easily drive 20-30 minutes for this pizza

Yes, we make the drive for this pizza place! Buzzards is the best locally!

I gave this yet another chance. 7.7 average is insane. I feel bad for people who haven’t experienced good pizza. My 5.4 is generous. $14 for these 3 slices on top of it being sub par pizza.

This is the local favorite for as long as I’ve been around here (1996). Cash only, on the beach, cold drinks, solid pizza!! Crust has a great crisp, all products are fire!!!! Toppings are loaded on, also many traditional toppings offered on slices. Indoor and outdoor seating. A staple in Indialantic Beach. Sauce is tasty and the cheese is a pool of lava.

Good crust and sauce. Nice flop. Little grease. Cheese had the most flavor. Definitely recommend the grandma’s slice.

Plain is good Heavy Grandma pizza is better and crispier

Memorable oceanside pizzeria. Always very solid. Lots of good memories there!

Looks good on the surface. Very floppy. Sauce is plain.

Decent cheese pie. Sweet sauce. A little greasy. Solid crust and undercarriage. Nothing special here, they likely do volume because of consistency and overall quality.

This place is my favorite in Fl hope Dave reviews it sometime 🤞

On the Dave scale probably a 7.1 but being the best pizza in town is worth a couple point bump. Last two times ordering it’s been a tad on the doughy side and more attention needs to be given to crisping up the crust more especially when I address it with them each time when ordering on the phone.

Nice presentation. Thin. Crispy. Little flop. So far best pie on the beach. Pass on the meatball and spaghetti stick to their pies.

My favorite in the area

Overall great pizza. Crust was crispy, ingredients were quality, definitely burned my face off though.

Just average pizza not as good as I remember

Right on the beach, good pizza. This was the Grandma slice.

I’ve been going to this Bizzaros Pizza for 26 years. I was pumped to actually give it a review when my family and I visited this year. Up until this year (2020) I would have given this pizza high 8s possibly into the 9s. I had to use a picture from 2 years ago because these slices were super greasy and not what I remember. The sauce is different, but the crust is still the way I remember...very bummed! Taking my family to the restaurant in Sat Beach to see if we can get some of the original taste that I remember.