The Original Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

Not sure what Dave was talking about. This pizza was amazing. Perfect crust (PERFECT) and flavorful sweet sauce. Best I’ve had on Staten Island (admittedly, just this and Denino’s - though I’ve been to Joe and Pat’s in East Village). Did not get the vodka pie, but I dislike mushrooms/prefer red sauce, so I don’t think I would’ve liked it.

Cheese Slice

All fresh ingredients, very tasty, yet lacking a little something I can’t figure out to send it over the bar

Crust was great mozzarel and sauce were under whelming could’ve use some basil

It’s so good that Dave and Frankie stole 2 slice before I took the picture! Grandma’s pie on point

Vodka pie is better than the cheese

"World famous vodka pie"....it was alright

Vodka slice. Good overall flavor. Were not cheap on the prosciutto either which is always a plus.

Goodfellas, Staten Island

Pizza Alla Vodka - Great flavorful sauce and excellent crust! Prosciutto was good

Mmmm saucy ... great mozzarella with even better crust . Solid pie.

It’s a Solid Slice! Nothing to Rave About. Decent Pizza.

Agree to disagree but...