The Original Little Italy

Good food, good vibes, nothing special

Decent pepperoni New York slice

Both slices were pretty bland. Like the grandma better - sauce had some decent flavor. Pepperoni had more of a cornmeal crust which isn’t my thing. Crust isn’t crispy enough. Not worth going to considering all the pizza places close by

Tried both the Sicilian and regular cheese. The crispiness on the regular slice made this pizza, with otherwise basic sauce and cheese

The little man nails it again. Great pizza. Nice little crunch.

Great cheese and sauce combination. Crust could be a bit thicker and have more crunch. Solid slice

Pepperoni was pretty greasy. The cheese slice was amazing. Great sauce.

Major grease, cheese a little chewy, but not a bad slice

Good side, very good buffalo slice too

Worse than dollar slice

Not too much flop, good cheese, decent sauce, standard football pizza. Would go again

Good crisp, good flop, somewhat under seasoned sauce but has good tomato flavor.

No bad! Good flavor and good sauce

Meatball slice is the best slice in midtown. Plain is not far behind. Nearly perfect crust. No flop. Good quality cheese. Not too greasy. Sauce is good but could be sweeter. Love this place.

Best slice in midtown. Solid crust but foldable. Great sauce/cheese proportion. These guys get it.