The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company

Thin, sauce is sweet, but center could be crispier

Good pie

Told me 30 min to pick it up way too long def sitting there for a while would have been a higher score prob

Generous on the rating here. Pizza had ZERO flavor. I did ask for it to be on the crispy side but they torched this poor pie. Had a white also which is a 1.7 and not photo worthy. Huge disappointment as i REALLY was looking for ward to trying this spot. Would have been better off ordering thin crust from dominos.

Pizza was perfectly cooked and delicious.

I have been eating this pizza for over 40 years. First it was at Pete’s Bar. Then Vitales on English town road and now here. TRUE BAR PIE.

Charming venue and nice staff. Good amount of sauce and enough dough cooked to provide the consistency of low flop. Plenty of cheese to give it a solid texture. The low grade is because all 3 major components (cheese sauce & dough) lack sufficient flavor.

Solid pizza looks better than it tastes!! Thin with some flop and crunch!!! I would repeat but not go out of my way for!!! I'll give it 6.8!! That's a review!! Extra review: worst meatballs I've ever had no exaggerating. Over seasoned and dry!!

I like it. Good crust, no flop. Really crisp bottom somewhat under. Not sure I understand other reviews on this place. Really good.

Don't go near this place. Not only did the pizza have three holes in it, was nearly raw on the bottom, and had a disgusting sauce, but when I posted a quick review on Google, the owner responded in a really unprofessional and rude way. From the bottom of my heart, I hope this place goes out of business. Looking at other reviews shows that this is definitely not the first time.

Incredible thin crust pie. Idk what everyone's deal is with this place, but I've taken out several times and its consistently fantastic.

Not everyone loves the burnt edges of their pies, but I think that’s what makes them special.

The pizza was a 5/10 but the service was a 0 and the bugs brings it to an overall -3/10

Great pie hot out of the oven. Mild flop on the fold. Very good overall.

My three favorite pizza places are Ralph’s in Nutley, Lazzaras in the city and The Original Thin Crust Pizza Company. Right up Dave’s alley, thin, well done and the taste is really good.

Fresh out oven, no flop and a lot of crisp

Elios frozen pizza is better. This is pure garbage and even had to wait 20 minutes for a pie in the middle of the day with zero customers

Not bad. Crispy, thin crust deliciousness. I might order mine a bit more well done next time but I’ll be back. I enjoyed it

Soggy pizza & hair in your chicken parm sandwich. Good if you like eating wax paper & hair.