The Pizza Pie

Great pizza every time! The breaded chicken and vodka sauce pizza is a strong recommendation!

Solid pizza for sure. Very happy with the execution and taste. We ate it the moment it came out of the oven. No flop. One would be hard pressed growing up in the NYC area to think this wouldn’t fit in easily up there. The guys making the pie are from South NJ.

My new favorite pizza discovery of 2024! Absolutely loved this pizza! Great cheese, great sauce and great crust! I can’t wait to go back!

Great pizza. Nice crunch on the crust, minimal flop. Maybe a bit too saucy, nice amount of cheese. I’ll definitely be back. Great job Rosario!

Great crust and cheese. He gets a 7.1 for making it right crispy and excellent cheese

Sauce a bit too sweet but good crisp, good crust maybe a tad heavy on the cheese. White was solid, wish buffalo had some spice.

Really good dough and cheese let down by a terrible sauce. Way more on the sweet side than robust side and it ruined every bite. I would taste flavorful cheese and get excited but then the sauce started coming in and ruined the whole damn party. With every bite my score kept going further south. A disappointment.

Pizza was fine/good, but don’t see myself returning. Would rather have Suprema or Sam’s (previously Uptown). And you can tell by the reviews from others that the doneness is inconsistent, some seem to have gotten more well-down (cheese more orange).

Good pizza, minimal flop, and good crisp. The sauce is a little clumpy so it doesn’t spread across the entire pizza, but overall, it’s pretty good. 7.9

One Bite everyone knows the rules!!! Pizza pie...good undercarriage, fresh tomato sauce, fresh cheese, good crisp!!! 8.2!!!!!