It was good. We liked the drunken grandma pie better. This pie was a flashback to Florham Park Roller Rink pizza in the 80s.
menzamenz3/1/21, 11:51 p.m.
Absolutely amazing!!! Grandma pizza!!! Sauce is delicious, fresh mozzarella & basil! Crust was crispy! Perfect pizza!
thepizzahulk2/28/21, 1:26 a.m.
The best bar pie in NJ comes from your local pizza joint. Yea you just read that right. The #BartsoolPie created by owner Scott Rafferty is the best pie in the state. And there was a pizza contest to prove it. And if that’s not enough he has some of the best specialty pies around. You don’t have to take my word for it or the 15,000+ people in the Facebook group just drop everything and get there ASAP tell him @ThePizzaHulk sent ya.....
larry.puentedelavega2/26/21, 2:50 a.m.
Mouth watering 🤤🤤🤤🤤!!!! Can’t wait to get home and munch away.......
danny.gonzalez72/26/21, 2:46 a.m.
My mom ordered me and my friends a nutella pizza and we loved it and played fortnite.
elvira.hirsch2/26/21, 2:37 a.m.
Grilled chicken Cesar Salad on Pizza! OMG! Whoever thought of this is a genius. The pizza base has a layer of melted Mozzarella and every bite is a piece of heaven.
lennoll12/25/21, 6:36 p.m.
Breaking the rules cuz this here Marg slice was reachin out to me and the plain looked just so.... well, plain. And yessir this was a tasty, crispy choice! So many options here... gotta stop by again.
hotelfire2/25/21, 2:07 a.m.
Barstool Pie = Thin, crisp, cheese had tang. Zero-flop. Must eat on-site. Could’ve used just a tad more sauce. Worth a 30 minute drive.
mcnulty2/25/21, 1:03 a.m.
Barstool Margarita. Zero flop. Crisp for days. Excellent mix of fresh and shredded mozzarellas. Only thing keeping it from an all time score is that the sauce could have been a little tangier.
dougie.dickman2/21/21, 6:04 p.m.
Solid pizza. We tried the regular and the Sicilian. The regular was a bit disappointing for the hype of it. The crust had a nice taste to it though. The scillion we tried is the one I recommend. Everything about it worked so well together. The regular pie dragged the score down but the scillian got it up. So I recommend the Scillian if you are to ever stop by this place. Overall solid stop.
michael.stefanelli12/18/21, 4:29 a.m.
Barstool Pie. Solid. Could use a little more taste or tang but still delicious. Crust was very good with nice crunch to it
ed.mckeown2/14/21, 1:10 a.m.
Legit very possible the best plain pie I’ve had... cooked perfectly, great sauce, great cheese
kevin.price2/13/21, 12:46 a.m.
10 for hospitality from Scott and the crew here at the apparently just crowned best pizza in NJ. Cooked well done amazing taste. This is the barstool pie too thinner crust some nice charring which is always earning brownie points. Theming of this place rocked!! Us Jersey guys gotta take the fight to Ct!