The Pizzeria of Bayport

Lots of hype . Lots of flop

Half Buffalo half regular. Was told to get the pie well done but Mark ‘The Pizza Don’ Lussos insisted we get it how they normally cook it so we could get a fair score. Buffalo 7.7, Regular 6.3. And that’s a pizza review.

Decent slice! Again, hard to get a great slice in this area. Rookie score but I rated Sal’s 7.1 which I prefer slightly better. No thrills slice, it’s solid; good flavor, very standard crust. Nothing special but good! Give it a shot!!

Review based solely off cheese slice, eaten first to ensure it was fresh. It was good. Sauce and cheese were good. Crust was thin but didn’t get crispy. I actually ordered a second cheese slice and asked them for it on the well done side and it still didn’t crisp up. That was disappointing. A crisp crust could have put this in the 8’s easily.

Fresh hot & crispy 👍🏼👍🏼

Underrated local spot

Lots of cheese and a crisp crust. Great slice

This is one solid slice. Great sauce, great cheese, nice crust. Owner is great guy too. Benny really knowns how to run a pizza joint.