The Pizzeria of Bayport

I absolutely loved this slice. Little greasy but that don’t bother me ay oh. Crispy, cheese and sauce were good. For a football slice, it was as good as it can get. The place is cool too, nice atmosphere, friendly service, and a lot of really great specialty slices. Will be back!

Good sauce. Cooked good. No flop.

Worth it hunndo P

Love the vibe of the place. Uniqueness across speciality slices and some new styles as well. The red sauce on regular comes in flat and overly cheesy. Would def go for other specialties though.

Marvelous😍🥹🤩😎

Typical Long Island slice. The other 3 locations have better quality. Too salty.

This football slice got sacked for a 10 yard loss on first down. No undercarriage, no crisp, was doughy, and a complete oil slick. A little disappointing, because the flavor was decent.

The specialty slice was borderline orgasmic. Cheese was solid, like eating a full bag of almonds.

Their Bayport is amazing (regular and Sicilian are both also good) and their white slice is amazing!

Bayport Pie, their version of Margherita. On the thin side. Very Good pie 👍