The Pizzeria of Islip

Not the best. The pizzeria tastes decent but had not crisp at all. Very doughy. Not terrible but not good either. I wouldn’t come back here.

Good crisp, overall needs something. Too thick for my style, sauce was bland.

They don’t have the Linderhurst location on here so I’ll throw it on the islip one. Bang average slice but the Cesar salad wrap was world class and the bar was flowing drinks on a Thursday night so the vibes are there. 🕺 take care brush ya hair

Good crust, not too cheesy

Really good pizza. Not too much flop a good crust, right amount of cheese and sauce. Definitely the best slice I’ve had in the islip area in a long time.

You deserve great pizza is the motto here…and it lives up to that! Crispy, thin, with a great undercarriage. Everything a football slice on Long Island should be.

Alla Vodka Margherita was just simply ok. Too much grease, and not enough Alla Vodka. Barely a Crust on the end, but the undercarriage was good.

The bakeri pie. Like an upside down Sicilian with a detroit style crust. Amazing slice overall

Delicious Detroit slice! Sauce is the showstopper. Not sweet and made with San Marzano tomatoes. Nice and crisp.

I hate the mall, I never go to the mall, for me the pizza has got to be special to get me to go to the mall. The pizza is better than standard mall pizza and would be a star outside of NY but this will not get me to the mall

So many people raving about this pizza in the mall, not mall pizza. Regular Slice 6.7 The margherita 6.9