The Sawmill

I haven’t had many slices that I had to force down. Sauce is awful.

This sucks

This looks about as good as it tasted. Sauce tasted like ragu, and cheese was weak. The crust was the only redeeming quality. To think people swear by this place. I had decent expectations and this did not live up to the hype. Sad day for the Seaside Heights flagship pizzeria.

Floppy but good beach pizza

Good taste but flop city

13 inch slice, sauce is good and crust is good

Plain slice. Pretty thin, and a decent crust. Could've been cooked a bit longer. Not very flavorful at all though.

Big and floppy boardwalk slice. Overall, the pizza was average. The taste was okay and the crust had a nice crunch. However, the undercarriage was floppy and didn’t have crisp. I wouldn’t put this pizza on my go to list of pizzas but still enjoy having a slice from here on occasion.

Actually think it’s the worst pizza on the boardwalk

Subpar pizza. No crisp even after asking for it well done. Boring flavor and too saucy.

Umm... totally below average pizza, under-cooked, blah flavor, greasy

Not what it used to be. Ingredients have been adjusted, used to be a staple on this boardwalk. Order a whole pie, although no flop, crust was not crisp. Sauce is a bit runny and oily, has a bit of a sharp spice to it too. Cheese is not high quality. Crust is just average. In the past it used to have better ingredients and crispier crust. Not terrible, but definitely was better in the past.

Not the best slice on the boardwalk. Too saucy, subpar flavor, no flop but no crisp at all.

Getting sexual HUGE slice but otherwise standard football

Nasty, cheese didn’t melt good. Sauce is super dark and from bar, used to come here but last time I’m coming here

Huge Slice. Surprisingly very crispy. Ingredients are basic as hell, but it was not bad at all.

Typical boardwalk pizza

Big boardwalk slice and minimal flop. The sauce is bland and the crust is crispy. A lot of cheese and oil which bumped up my score, but all around it’s not very flavorful. I have been coming here since I was a kid, and it has definitely changed in flavor.