For some reason this place has 2 locations on this app. Anyway it gives me a chance to do a followup review. The more I ate this pizza the more I regret giving it a 4.3 as this pizza got worse as I ate it. Maybe a bad night? Soooooo salty. Almost inedible halfway through the second slice. Maybe the salty crust? Probably the sauce that tastes like tomato paste from the grocery store?
phillypizzaguy1237/4/20, 5:33 p.m.
This is my 2nd review for this place. Definitely would recommend going here. By far the best place in Gettysburg. Order the Mushroom if you get a chance. Multiple cheese, different mushrooms, and an egg to top it off. Best mushroom pizza I’ve ever had.
kyle.reecher4/3/20, 4:44 p.m.
Wouldn’t go there every week, but the margherita was decent. Worth at least trying for sure.
greg.mclucas3/1/20, 12:16 a.m.
Good taste, high end wood fire pizzas. Light on sauce and cheese
marcus.dulik1/26/20, 12:42 a.m.
For being margherita pizza. I’ve been in Gettysburg for a couple days now and heard some locals ranting and raving about different pizza joints that were straight trash.. maybe I came in on a good night but the fresh mozzarella and spicy sauce won me over. Wood fired pizza you have to kinda hit it right on but the crust was just right.
mgriff62110/1/19, 10:16 p.m.
Great location and atmosphere but it’s lacking sauce and flavor. Decent slice but nothing to go back for. If you want good pizza GO TO THE MARKETS IN HANOVER!
tyler.shuff8/12/19, 6:13 p.m.
Some slices missing cheese. Extra crispy crust, very mod pizza like. Weak pizza for the price. Comparative to box pizza.
izpiz7/13/19, 1:14 p.m.
Was really excited to try this new place. Love the aesthetic of the redesign and was expecting great things. Pizza was very pretentious and very mediocre. Crust was covered in loose flour, sauce was weird, and cheese was pretty good. Disappointed.