The Village Idiot

Wow, I think Portnoy went a little low with this! All my in laws say this is the best in Toledo! I love the cracker thin style. Great sauce and cheese! They do charge $2 for to go and takes about an hour to make. Would love to go back and eat inside soon.

Very excellent Chicago tavern style pizza

Best pizza in Toledo. No question. Thick cut pepperoni and Italian sausage. Cannot just do cheese here. The score is wrong.

Wish it was better. Sauce was okay and crust was alright but cheese wasn’t great and kinda seemed fake. Liked the oregano on top. It’s a good pie at an awesome venue.

already ate the pizza.

Super thin, good crunch, good char, no flop. Solid pizza

Bar pizza at its finest!

Perfect crisp. No flop. Could use more pepperonis, but still has enough for a great score. Not greasy whatsoever and cures hangovers.

It’s not their all cheese .. but this pizza is banging !! Amazing .. one of the best in the area !!

Solid Bar Pie

Good crust. Fancy toppings available. Plain cheese was pretty average. Good but average.

What a pizzeria is supposed to be.

Meat Pizza, fantastic

Was looking for it to be great but didn’t live up to the hype. Thin and crispy crust but flavor of sauce was a disappointment.

Def want bigger pizzas, but the taste was great and the consistency was pretty good too. Could do with a little more sauce

Got a plain cheese which is what I’m basing the score of off and a specialty pickle pizza. The plain cheese was pretty good, nothing crazy but cooked pretty much perfect with a great thin crust. Sauce could’ve been better but still a good ratio to crust and cheese. The cheese was better than most places. Now for the pickle pie... wow! Easily a 8.9. One of the better pizza’s I’ve ever had, granted I’m a big pickle fan. Definitely worth it! Awesome atmosphere inside as well!

Good crust, good pizza for the price. 10 bucks bar pizza.

Absolutely electric crispy crust. Sauce could be better. Good amount of cheese. In a non-Covid world you can't beat the atmosphere.