About Thick and Thin Pizza & Restaurant
236 Yelp Reviews
mikezinho5/11/23, 12:58 a.m.
I've ordered here many times and its always consistent. My rating is strictly for the Grandma Pizza, because that is what I order. I've had their round pie. It's a solid 7.7 and their silician is an 8.0
jacrissppy9/4/22, 4:54 a.m.
A very nice little place. Gives you the nice traditional Italian family vibes. This was very well put together pie. The sauce was really on point. The cheese was great as well. Could use a little more crispness and this pizza would be out of the park. Will absolutely be back for this and to try the Sicilian pie next. Definitely check it out!
jblanco1/3/22, 3:14 p.m.
This is a review on the sicilian style/ thick crust. Overall this was pretty good, a little too heavy for sicilian, but still good. Best part was it tasted better when I recooked it the 2nd/3rd day
drew.summa9/27/21, 2:16 p.m.
Asked for well done, did not come well done. Tasted great but a little too chewy as there was zero crunch on the bottom crust.
colossalcrust5/29/21, 12:02 p.m.
Good taste, little greasy, thin and crispy with little flop. It’s good football pizza
williet5243/17/21, 4:46 a.m.
Dave you gotta go!!! Get fresh whole pie not the slice. Best in south Florida!!!
jon.val1/27/21, 1:13 a.m.
The dough is fantastic for South Florida, excellent craftsmanship by the pizza man, great crust to pizza ratio, cooked nicely with a great crisp, no flop... the cheese and sauce were the downfall of this slice, a little too greasy... I suggest adding some parm cheese and red pepper flakes to amplify the flavors. BTW: great garlic knots and calamari! We will be back to try the Sicilian and other menu options. Thats a review.
erik.brinkmann1/8/21, 1:09 a.m.
Thin, crispy, nice undercarriage, not to much sauce so you don't get the slip and slide.
dkrames11/14/20, 6:25 p.m.
Little too much flop for my liking. Not bad by any means but way too doughy for being called “thin”.
whatchutalkinboutwillis7/29/20, 12:19 a.m.
This pizza is great and the place has been here for years. Dad and son making the pies! Sauce has good tang and the pie is always consistent. Traditional thin NY style pizza.
noja6/14/20, 1:12 a.m.
I mean come on. If you like a slice that’s extra doughy, extra greasy, then you found your spot. Nothing special about the sauce. Ask for it well done and you still get a floppy pie. The picture looks much better than it tastes.
bigz-pizza3/10/20, 5:04 p.m.
The thick as they call it was Great.crispy bottom with light and airy inside with right amount of cheese and sauce ..Thin was pretty good but I am gonna give them the score of the thick...if you like Sicilian then this is the spot
irishpizzagenral9/2/19, 7:26 p.m.
Ok, we got a Hurricane Dorian special, BREAKING NEWS... Thick and Thin Pizza & Restaurant, sandlefoot plaza. Place is 34 years old, because the pizza is Great! Almost no flop, perfect cheese to sauce ratio, crunch and taste of crust was incredible. Sauce needed a little more salt for me. All in all a great slice! One bite Everyone Knows the rules, 8.4! Go and get it!!
bdrill8/11/19, 12:04 a.m.
May have been an 8.4 had it not been for the oil. Overall a damn good slice of pizza.
pizzageneral7/22/19, 4:58 p.m.
One of my local favorites.. has to be eaten there.. Gold metal slice has all the right flavors.. they definitely use two different cheeses on their pizza.. Sauce gives a lot of flavor as well as cheese.. Cheese creates too much grease.. but also offers flavor.. crunch on every bite.. just too greasy!! Could have scored higher with no grease..