Sauce was good but it was under baked and floppy.
dancostarell7/16/22, 6:39 p.m.
Good pizza, gets the job done. I’ll have a full review posted eventually on my YouTube channel, make sure to check it out and subscribe for reviews of pizza and other food as well. YouTube.com/firstbitewithdan
1 view•0 likes
southside.chica.go2/11/22, 1:46 a.m.
Pepperoni: crust has a lot of flavor. Sauce is also tangy and has a great flavor. I wish the bottom was a little crispier, lots of flop. If in the area, definitely a repeat. Definitely a repeat. 😉
heath.mcallister9/1/21, 7:07 p.m.
Decent crust but some slices had more flop. Sauce and cheese are okay tasting.
cody.vernotzy5/2/21, 12:46 a.m.
Cheese Kinda plan. Really good dough though. Going to have to give their other pies a try.
cheeseofoshow4/9/21, 11:26 p.m.
This is a SOLID pizza. Good sauce, flavorful and soft crust with some good crisp on the bottom. Not too much flop. Far better than the place down the street and for half the price! Definitely my new go to pizza spot.
worldofmike8/22/19, 11:39 p.m.
This is my second time coming to Times Square Pizza while the first time I was here was a long time ago I don't really remember it being that great then but that in no way affects this review, well the pizza wasn't great it wasn't bad either there was just something about the crust and the minimal cheese that really turns me off what I did like about the pizza is that it was well done and it had a decent crunch to it as far as the name of the place goes Times Square Pizza I'm from New York and all you'll find in Time Square is chain pizza places so perhaps consider a different name but I'm sure that's not possible at this point I'll come back again and give it another shot because it seems like a lot of people have good reviews of this place
matt.fitzgerald10/12/18, 5:17 p.m.
Good pizza, good sauce, would've scored higher if the crust was a little crisper.
mike.decker8/31/18, 9:01 p.m.
One bite everyone knows the rules! First off, the fact that this place is owned by one of the kids from the Sandlot instantly makes it cool. And he is the one in the back making the pie. Legit. Great pizza. Just the right amount of flop and no drip. Crust a little tough but the flavor in the cheese and rest of the pizza far outweighs that! The picture doesn’t do it justice cause I dove into the pie when I got home before I remembered I had to compete the review.