Tino's Pizza

Definitely recommend!

For college area definitely plus pizza. No frills and the way the cheese is cooked makes this slice.

Semi-football pizza, but with a great undercarriage and crisp with almost no flop. The meat lovers was a little greasy, but mostly due to the quality of the meats. A really solid pie.

Basic hoe

This slice has some HEFT. The cold cheese melts with the hot pie to make a satisfying cheese pull. Solid slice with or without the cold cheese

Great people but the pizza was a little mid. Very greasy and the cheese was an odd texture

Blacked and this shi slaps

Stumbled upon this gem with tonypeporoni late night adventure, no flop, minimal oil, and crispy just how papa likes it XD

Late night Tom foolery with my fellow barrel Johnny two phones 📞 ☎️. Place is oney staple good crust little lite sauce and w formagio

Born and raised in the Pizza Capitol of the world (New Haven). This is very similar.

Football pie with Decent crisp and flavor

Famous for this cold cheese slice. It’s way too much cheese and makes the whole thing kind of cold. I shook off the cold cheese, and underneath is a decent slice. Crispy and thin, with good sauce, but a little dry.

Ok so this is not your typical review. Being known for the cold cheese slice of course that’s what to had to get. While it is a gimmick that works in a college town and is quite frankly good it doesn’t really enhance the pizza at all, in fact once you move past the hype of trying the cold cheese slice it actually kind of takes away from the pizza. The extra cheese drowns out the taste of the sauce for the most part. However the crust is phenomenal on this slice and really pulls it all together. If you’re in the area try it, if your drunk there’s probably nothing better in the world, but as simply a pizza compared to other it’s average.

Their cold cheese slice is revolutionary even with the extra cheese aI got worried about the spread of sauce but I was pleasantly surprised with a great tasting sauce. The crust is also phenomenal definitely understand why they are regarded one of the best in Oneonta.

The original cold cheese. Phenomenal ingredients great staff near perfect under carriage. My FAVORITE place in New York State hands down. Will be a life long customer. Score says it all. Love this place

Decent pizza, prefer regular cheese over this. Gimmick in my opinion and lazy. Drunk college kids should be able to eat normal pizza.

A really good slice with a great crispy crust and no flop. Not much flavor in the sauce but there’s enough. The cheese is not that gooey and it is a little greasy. Overall a good slice.

I like it!

This pizza is overrated. Pizza always tastes like it sat for a day or two