One bite everybody knows the rules. Nice crisp thin crust. Appropriate amount of flop, not very tangy sauce but plenty of it. Better than it needs to be for the location and I appreciate that. Thumbs up
stihlman8/26/21, 9:27 p.m.
Wow - great pizza. I was skeptical that it would hold up against other Derby stars but it did. My one small critique was that the crust was slightly too crispy. Not by much but just enough to notice. Overall a great slice.
ct-nyc-pizzadude6/18/21, 4:58 p.m.
Great bar pizza… great specialty pizza’s too… small pie or a large pie you can’t go wrong
mike.fernino5/10/21, 12:08 a.m.
Classic thin crust pizza. Very distinctive sauce and cheese taste. If you like garlic you will like the sauce.
dam0007bass2/21/21, 12:54 p.m.
I had ate here once before on a friends recommendation for the baked stuffed shrimp pizza. An amazing pie but didn’t review as I’m bias to a plain cheese pizza. Well I tried the plain and WOW! The crust was the perfect thickness crisp underneath yet not too soft on the top. Great amount of cheese. Sauce has incredible flavor just the right amount of spice without anything being overkill. This is now my new favorite plain pie. Period.
bigdaddyapizza2/19/21, 6:43 p.m.
After all the hype I had to check it out. Safe to say this one lives up to it all. Nice crispy thin crust and cooked just right. The sausage is pretty close to Zuppardi’s. Had the stuffed shrimp pie also. Very good but the plain and sausage is where it’s at.
arvind.singh11/24/20, 2:59 a.m.
Great pie. The cheese and sauce of NYC, the thin crust of a pie you would get in Stamford at a place like Colony or Riko’s, but cooked New Haven style. Highly recommend!
russoj887/19/20, 8:10 p.m.
0 flop. Great crisp. Sauce and crust could have had better flavor, but very good overall.
heather.giaimo4/2/20, 12:16 a.m.
Steiner stinger with white truffle honey! The combo of flavors is amazing!
kj.mano2/23/20, 12:46 a.m.
tastes pretty good. menu says ‘new haven style’ but a little too white on the bottom.
billy.waitt2/9/20, 4:08 a.m.
Had a pepperoni pie, stuffed shrimp pie and a Big Mac pie. Love the thin crust with a little char, and the stuff shrimp pie was out of this world .
chuck.kalander2/1/20, 11:35 p.m.
A good bar style pie. Very good cheese and crust. Two things keep this pie from being in the mid 8’s. The sauce - tasteless and not much of it at all. Might have been the least amount of sauce I’ve ever had on a pie. The service - normally I don’t count this towards the score, but had to make an exception here. We dined in and the service was painfully slow. It was a Sat afternoon and it was just us and two other tables. Only one waitress working and she was taking care of the tables, pickup orders and answering the phone. She would disappear for 20 min at a time. Pizza was good and I will give it another chance and see if the service has improved.