Tobin's Pizza

I generally love this style of pizza and it looks fantastic. But something about the taste isn’t quite right. The cheese tastes a little sour for my liking.

First eating at this Blo/No old staple. Weird vibe all around. Outside of the cheese and sauce being solid a lot of meh here.

The pizza is pretty average!! There is not enough sauce, but the customer service makes up for it. The owner is very funny and the waitress is awesome. Would come for the wings and customer service again!!!

Pizza was under cooked, cheese was different, sauce had vinaigrette taste

Cheese pizza: Bland, very limited sauce, looks like a pre-fab crust, crust is chalky - DiGiorno is better, unfortunately (hoped I’d like it since it’s a long time Bloomington staple)

Really good sorta party style pizza. We opted for the Michelio’s sauce which we were told is a bit more garlicky than Tobin’s. The cheese and pepperoni was awesome and the crust had a nice crunch to it. The sauce had good flavor to it but left me wishing I had some Italian herb blend seasoning to put on it.

This is voted best pizza in Normal, IL but I'm fairly confident we drove to Bloomington, IL to get it. People were not the most friendly and there were balls of pizza dough everywhere. Decent looking pie. Again cut party style. Crust is kind of strange. Cheese is spot on. Can't put my finger on it. Gets better with each slice. This is the clubhouse leader in Bloomington-Normal.

Ordered a “deep dish” pizza and it was only about an inch thick with no sauce. It was just cheese tomato slices some seasoning and the breading/crust. It was extremely dry and a large ran me $27.05. Very disappointed just go to Giordano’s.

Easily the best pizza you’re going to get around here. Good crunch, good sauce, good tastes. All you need for a basic pizza

Hands down best pizza in town

Doing a review since my husband didn’t order pizza. Best pizza in town easily.

Micheleo's thick crust pizza is the best at Tobin’s

Listen, all the people who are rating this pizza as amazing, you all don’t know pizza. You just got caught *Steven A Smith voice*. It’s okay really greasy, I’m not tasting the great sauce flavor everyone’s hyping up. It’s okay pizza nothing more nothing less.

Not a lot of great pizza options in the area. This is easily the best.

Great sauce! Crunchy crust. Great ratio of sauce to cheese to crust!

Good pie first every review one bite everyone knows the rules