This was an average pie that I had much higher hopes for. The consistency of the dough and crust was not bad but bland, the cheese tasted good but by the second slice the copious amounts of grease had made the cheese less than desirable. Sauce wasn’t bad at all. Now I won’t say I hated it or that it was bad, but it’s not going to break a 6 today. I’ve heard good things though from others, maybe I’m missing something, will try again another time to make sure I’m not wrong here.
william.hawkins11/10/20, 10:50 p.m.
Apparently I forgot to post this. This was some solid pizza. Can’t wait to go back on my next trip to tampa st. Pete
7 views•0 likes
michael.mario9/12/20, 12:49 a.m.
Little St Pete Flop, this pizza is performing as well as the Rays this season. I’m from queens but for Florida this is solid pizza.
theodore7/3/20, 1:50 a.m.
Great NY style pie. Only complaint is it’s greasy but seriously still tastes good!
u_wanna_pizza_me3/9/20, 11:12 p.m.
Alright Frankie...Toby’s Little Italy. Neat spot in a strip mall and much bigger place than expected from the parking lot. Back room styled like NYC...good, pizza shop...but the pie didn’t hold up as much as I’d like. Football pizza that they go very heavy on the cheese, despite not asking for it. Typically a good thing, but in this case it really overpowered the sauce and dough and made it overly greasy. The crust was solid with good crunch and the pepperoni was spicy and tasty. But too much of a good thing (cheese) didn’t allow it to mesh together to break the 8’s...
just some.dude2/27/20, 12:55 a.m.
Bummer- undercooked😩 major flop, not crisp. Cheese and sauce was very good- Typically this pizza is much better
court.marshall12/8/19, 5:54 p.m.
Best pizza in St Pete by far but only if you eat it there. Very thin crust and doesn’t travel well but eating it in house is incredible
mark.salty7/26/19, 11:35 p.m.
This is average pizza at best. I had pretty big flop with grease dripping off the cheese. The mozzarella quality is pretty good but the sauce is watery and the crust needed more crunch. Not impressed at all and won’t be back.
hollywood657/3/19, 7:04 p.m.
Minimal flop good crust Decent crisp sauce could’ve used a little more Tang. solid slice
brian.hill6/4/19, 7:51 p.m.
Went in with super high expectations. Wasn’t let down per say but. Eh.
anthony.constantinople5/12/19, 12:32 a.m.
A solid slice! Good flop good crust nice amount of sauce and cheese.
__frenchyyy__3/28/19, 11:03 p.m.
Extreme flop Puddlesof grease Still tasty Extra crispy crust which I like 6.2 cause it’s my hometown spot I grew up on
dieselpizza3/18/19, 12:14 a.m.
Good pizza, lots of St Pete flop, I wish I was a little crispier, cheese is pretty good, sauce had a nice little tang to it.
ron.jeremy32/22/19, 12:56 a.m.
I good slice of NY style pizza. A little greasy but overall it's above average. Cheese is really good and crust is solid. I wouldn't mind having this again.
mjay7272/16/19, 2:40 a.m.
Did extra cheese. Were they fucking with me? The dough was a little too chewy. That being said the sauce and flavor of the dough was fanfuckingtastic! Fresh dough. Shit varies. I will 100% try again and hope for more "tender" dough.
tiffany.citek12/10/18, 12:10 a.m.
GOOD PIZZA. Great ambiance, fast service, good times! Definitely a place you must visit in St. Pete.
ryan.q611/8/18, 5:36 p.m.
Good pizza with little flop and grease. Crust had a good crunch and the cheese and sauce were on point.