Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza

Good pizza

A solid pie. Cheese and sauce was good and the under carriage was a bit floppy but still decent. it’s a pretty thin pizza so if that’s your style you’ll like it

Toby knows what he is doing. Amazing pies & lethal garlic knots. Also, for the people who care, they have Poppin Pink Lemonade. Must try if you live in Tampa Bay!

Not the best but far from the worst. The kids like the pizza and loved the garlic rolls. For me it’s a solid slice.

This pizza was worse than I expected after seeing the Prez and community reviews. I found it to be super meh. Just a step above Joey Brooklyns 🤢. Oily, floppy all the way to the crust, undercarriage had no crunch, crust was good, sauce is not unique from the next pizza shop, the pepperoni is good quality. I’ll stick to my normal shop that the Prez hasn’t hit yet.

Solid NY pizza

Not sure what Dave is talking about. (Midder than mid) White pizza with Ricotta & the Cheesesteaks were better.

Decent pizza way too much sauce to cheese ratio

Review via proxy. Next flight in from Ky we stoppin’ in! My friend David and his letter score had to be converted to numeric for the app. David’s thrift store rating app coming soon!

Solid slice. Great crust, not too greasy.

Had the Pizza made well done. No flop, cheese and sauce was amazing one of the better places in the Bay area.

Wish it had a little more sauce great bread and cheeese though. I would not pass up in a pinch which is what happened to me today. Decent nice flop worth the try maybe for you

Really good pizza and great prices! People in the store were actively talking about how good it is. I’d go back for sure!

Good undercarriage, major flop. Whole slice was crispy throughout, which was nice. Crust was good but a little burnt flavor. Pepperoni was basic, not a lot of flavor or spice to it. I liked the cheese. 6.9 there ya go that's a review

Really good flavor! The flop is wild so it’s constantly falling apart but in general a good spot.

Undercarriage was great! Nice and crispy. Sauce to cheese was perfect. My new best slice in st pete.

Had to come back for another score…there’s no place better in St Pete for a NY Pie. Our go to…

Decent pizza. Sauce was tangy. Crust was a little bland with poor undercarriage. I’d have again.

Went with well done this time. Knocked it right into the next bracket. Might be the best NY style I’ve had in the area